Skip to main content
    Food & Wine Classic in CharlestonNovember 13–15, 2026Pearl members: $500 off passes
    Pearl app wordmark
    Lucia Pizza of Avenue X, Restaurant in New York City
    Restaurant
    New York Times 2025

    Lucia Pizza of Avenue X

    Pizza · Sheepshead Bay-Manhattan Beach-Gerritsen Beach, New York City

    Restaurant in New York City, United States

    The Read

    Heritage-Rooted New York Slice

    Price

    $20–30per person

    Dress

    Casual

    Why go

    Lucia Pizza of Avenue X is a strong Brooklyn pizza detour for diners who care more about the pie than a polished room. The New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City 2025 recognition gives it a real reason to be on the shortlist, but treat it as a casual small-group stop rather than a private dining plan.

    About Lucia Pizza of Avenue X

    Lucia Pizza of Avenue X is a New York City pizza venue with casual dress and daily hours from 12–10 PM. It is a reasonable choice when the goal is a direct pizza meal rather than a heavily structured dining plan.

    The main recognition is a New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City 2025 mention. That gives Lucia Pizza of Avenue X a stronger reason for attention than a generic pizza stop. Plan around pizza, casual attire, and daily 12–10 PM hours.

    Use it for a New York City pizza detour, not a formal group plan

    The strongest grounded use case is a low-friction meal built around pizza. Hours run daily from 12–10 PM, so the schedule gives some flexibility across the day and evening.

    Because there is no private-room, seat-count, reservation, or event-planning detail in the available profile, group planning should stay conservative.

    What the recognition changes for the decision

    The New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City 2025 mention matters because it separates Lucia Pizza of Avenue X from a purely generic pizza choice. It does not turn the meal into a tasting-menu decision, and it should not be approached like one. The grounded reason to go is simple: pizza at a casual New York City venue with confirmed daily hours.

    For a first-timer, the practical read is clear. Lucia Pizza of Avenue X is worth considering if the plan is centered on pizza and the timing works with its daily 12–10 PM schedule.

    Quick reference: pizza, casual dress code, daily 12–10 PM hours, New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City 2025 recognition.

    The takeVibe and best for
    Venue detailsCozy
    Know before you goBefore you book
    Recognition and awards1 source
    Also considerAlternatives

    Planning details

    Hours
    Monday: 12–10 PM · Tuesday: 12–10 PM
    Location
    2201 Avenue X, Brooklyn, NY 11235
    Website
    lucia.pizza
    Phone
    (718) 313-0999
    Restaurant contextNew York City, United States
    Explore New York CityNearby
    Around this placeMore Pearl picks
    The take

    The Take

    The Vibe

    Lucia Pizza of Avenue X reads like a neighborhood inheritance rather than a trend-driven newcomer. The owner’s family opened a Brooklyn pizzeria four decades ago, giving the room a learned and lived-in feel. The service pace and restrained menu underscore a relaxed, unforced temperament: this is a place built for steady, considered meals rather than theatrical dining. The result is quietly charming and rooted in local Italian-American pizza culture, a Brooklyn spot that registers as a continuation of tradition rather than a reinvention.

    Best For

    Lucia is best for low-key neighborhood evenings where the meal is the point rather than the spectacle. The review frames the pizzeria as part of Sheepshead Bay’s longstanding Italian-American food culture, so it suits family dinners and casual gatherings that appreciate technique and tradition. The restaurant fits repeat visits and paced meals, making it a good choice for locals and anyone seeking a focused pizza dinner that rewards attention to crust and composition.

    Ordering Tips

    Approach the menu as the review suggests: begin with the foundational ‘original pizza’ to register the kitchen’s crust strategy, then move into more assertive pies. Signature offerings include vodka pizza, grandma pie and margherita pie, and a clam version references New Haven traditions; sampling across those categories reveals how the kitchen negotiates tradition and energy. Prioritize the simpler, sauce-and-basil base to assess the crust, then try a specialty pie to see how toppings shift the argument.

    Venue details

    Ambiance

    Small, clean space with a few tables, pleasant atmosphere featuring Italian posters on the walls.

    Tags

    Vibe

    CozyClassic

    Best For

    Casual HangoutFamily

    Experience

    Open Kitchen

    At the Table

    Dress Code
    Casual
    Noise Level
    Conversational
    Service Style
    Casual
    Meal Pacing
    Quick Bite
    Capacity
    Intimate
    Kitchen
    Traditional
    Menu Format
    A la carte

    Signature Dishes

    • vodka pizza
    • grandma pie
    • margarita pie
    Know before you go

    Know Before You Go

    Getting there
    2201 Avenue X, Brooklyn, NY 11235

    Planning details

    Hours

    Monday
    12–10 PM
    Tuesday
    12–10 PM
    Wednesday
    12–10 PM
    Thursday
    12–10 PM
    Friday
    12–10 PM
    Saturday
    12–10 PM
    Sunday
    12–10 PM

    Location

    2201 Avenue X, Brooklyn, NY 11235 · Directions

    (718) 313-0999

    lucia.pizza

    Recognition and awards

    Also consider

    Where to go if this does not fit

    If the group wants a pizza night with a clearer bar or sit-down feel in New York City, cross-shop See No Evil Pizza. If value and a disclosed $$ tier matter more than the Avenue X detour, look at Seppe Pizza Bar.

    Restaurant context

    How it compares for New York pizza plans

    Lucia Pizza of Avenue X is the more focused Brooklyn detour if the priority is pizza with a serious recognition signal and easy planning. Seppe Pizza Bar and See No Evil Pizza are better cross-shops when the group wants a clearer bar-style or sit-down pizza night in New York City, especially with a $$ price signal attached.

    Brennan Carr is the better fit if the meal needs to feel less pizza-specific and more like a broader New York stop. Timber Pizza Co has the clearer value cue at $, but it is outside the metro set, so it is not a practical substitute for a Brooklyn meal. Zuppardi's Apizza belongs in the conversation for pizza depth, not for same-night New York convenience.

    For flexibility, Lucia is the choice in this group. For ambiance, Seppe Pizza Bar or See No Evil Pizza are safer picks if the room is part of the decision. For a pizza-first route through southern Brooklyn, Lucia is the cleaner recommendation.

    Explore New York City

    Around this place
    Read more on Pearl

    Discover more on Pearl

    Unlock the full Lucia Pizza of Avenue X guide in Pearl, including awards, comparisons, FAQs, planning details, and nearby places.

    Compare Lucia Pizza of Avenue X

    Lucia Pizza of Avenue X and similar venues
    VenueLocationCuisineAwardsPrice
    Lucia Pizza of Avenue XNew York CityPizza
    2025 New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City
    Brennan CarrNew York CityNew YorkNo published awards
    Seppe Pizza BarNew York CityPizza
    2025 Michelin Plate
    $$
    Zuppardi’s ApizzaWest HavenPizza
    2026 OAD Cheap Eats in North America Recommended2024 OAD Cheap Eats in North America Ranked · #1022023 OAD Cheap Eats in North America in Ranked · #94
    Timber Pizza CoWashington, D.C.Pizza
    2025 OAD Cheap Eats in North America Ranked · #5362025 Michelin Plate2024 OAD Cheap Eats in North America Ranked · #5162024 Michelin Plate
    $
    See No Evil PizzaNew York CityPizza
    2025 Michelin Plate
    $$

    How Lucia Pizza of Avenue X compares with similar nearby venues.

    FAQ

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What should I order at Lucia Pizza of Avenue X?

    Pizza is the cuisine at Lucia Pizza of Avenue X in New York City. The New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City 2025 mention makes it a more notable pick than a generic pizza stop.

    Is daytime or evening better at Lucia Pizza of Avenue X?

    Lucia Pizza of Avenue X is open every day from 12–10 PM.

    What should a first-timer know about Lucia Pizza of Avenue X?

    It is a casual New York City pizza venue with daily 12–10 PM hours and New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City 2025 recognition.