Hotel in New York City, United States
McCarren Hotel & Pool
150Pearl PointsPool access, Williamsburg location, seasonal value.
About McCarren Hotel & Pool
McCarren Hotel & Pool is Williamsburg's pool-anchored mid-range option, best booked in shoulder season (April–May or September–October) when rates soften but the experience holds. Summer delivers the full pool-and-neighbourhood package at peak prices; winter drops the rate but loses the hook. Easy to book year-round outside of peak summer weeks.
Quick Verdict
McCarren Hotel & Pool is Williamsburg's most recognisable summer hotel, built around a rooftop pool that draws both guests and day-pass visitors through the warmer months. Book here between November and March and you will pay meaningfully less for a room that is the same building, same location, and same access to the neighbourhood. The pool is closed, but the tradeoff is a lower rate and a quieter property. If the pool is your reason for booking, time it right — late spring and early summer give you the full experience before peak-season pricing takes hold.
Who Should Book
First-timers to Brooklyn who want a hotel with a sense of place rather than a chain lobby will find McCarren a serviceable base. It sits at 160 N 12th St in Williamsburg, within walking distance of the waterfront, Roberta's, and the L train for Manhattan access. For guests arriving in summer, the pool is the differentiating factor: few Brooklyn hotels offer anything comparable at a mid-range price point. For guests arriving in winter, the value case is stronger on rate alone, but the experiential hook is gone. In that scenario, consider whether Ace Hotel Brooklyn suits you better — it holds its appeal year-round through programming and dining.
Seasonal Pricing Angle
McCarren's rate-to-experience ratio shifts significantly by season. Summer demand from pool-seekers and Williamsburg visitors pushes rates up; the off-season brings the same room at a discount with less competition for booking. If your trip is flexible, shoulder season, late September through October, or April to early May, is where you get the best of both: pool access is possible in the warmer weeks, and rates have not yet climbed to peak levels. Book well ahead for June through August; availability tightens fast and rates follow. The rest of the year, booking a few days out is generally direct.
Practical Details
The hotel is at 160 N 12th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, easily reached via the L train (Bedford Ave stop is a short walk). Williamsburg restaurant and bar options are dense in this corridor, so dining out is easy. For a broader picture of what to do nearby, see our full New York City restaurants guide, our full New York City bars guide, and our full New York City experiences guide. For comparison shopping across Brooklyn and Manhattan, browse our full New York City hotels guide.
Quick reference: Williamsburg, Brooklyn | Booking difficulty: Easy | Leading rate window: November–March and shoulder season (April–May, Sept–Oct).
Frequently Asked Questions
How does McCarren Hotel & Pool compare to nearby hotels?
McCarren is the clearest choice in Williamsburg if pool access is your priority — no comparable hotel in the immediate neighbourhood offers the same setup. Ace Hotel Brooklyn is the stronger pick for nightlife-adjacent energy and design credentials; Pendry Manhattan West suits business travellers who need Manhattan proximity. McCarren's advantage is its sense of place: it functions as a Williamsburg destination, not just a place to sleep.
Is McCarren Hotel & Pool good for business travel?
It works for business travel only if your meetings are in Brooklyn or lower Manhattan and you want a less corporate stay. The Williamsburg location at 160 N 12th St is a short walk from the Bedford Ave L stop, so Manhattan is reachable, but the commute adds friction. For standard corporate travel, Pendry Manhattan West or The Ludlow Hotel will reduce transit overhead.
When is the best time to book McCarren Hotel & Pool?
Book off-season if rate is your priority. Summer demand from pool guests and Williamsburg foot traffic pushes prices up significantly, and you are effectively paying a premium for pool access you may share with day-pass visitors. Spring and autumn offer better rate-to-room value; the pool is less of a draw, but the neighbourhood and hotel remain fully operational.
How is the dining at McCarren Hotel & Pool?
Dining details are not documented in our current data for McCarren, so we can't give a reliable verdict on the restaurant specifically. What the address does give you is immediate access to one of Brooklyn's densest concentrations of restaurants and bars — Williamsburg along Bedford Ave and the surrounding blocks covers nearly every format and price point, which reduces dependence on the hotel's own food offering.
What is check-in like at McCarren Hotel & Pool?
Specific check-in times and policies are not confirmed in our current data. For summer arrivals, plan around pool-season crowds: the hotel draws non-guests via day passes, so the lobby and pool areas will be busier than a typical hotel arrival. check the venue's official channels at 160 N 12th St or via their website to confirm early check-in availability before a summer stay.
Location
160 N 12th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249
New York City, United States
Compare McCarren Hotel & Pool
| Venue | Awards | Booking Difficulty |
|---|---|---|
| McCarren Hotel & Pool | Easy | |
| Aman New York | Michelin 3 Key, World's 50 Best | Unknown |
| The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel | Michelin 2 Key, World's 50 Best | Unknown |
| Pendry Manhattan West | Michelin 2 Key | Unknown |
| Ace Hotel Brooklyn | Michelin 1 Key | Unknown |
| The Ludlow Hotel | Michelin 1 Key | Unknown |
Side-by-side comparison to help you decide where to book.
Also Consider
- Aman New York, Notable alternative
- The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, Notable alternative
- Pendry Manhattan West, Notable alternative
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn, Notable alternative
- The Ludlow Hotel, Notable alternative
How It Compares
McCarren sits in a different tier from Manhattan luxury options like Aman New York or The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, those properties offer service depth and room quality that McCarren does not compete with, and they price accordingly. If you are weighing Manhattan versus Brooklyn, Pendry Manhattan West is a closer comparison on style and positioning, though it lacks a pool and sits in a different neighbourhood. For guests who want Manhattan proximity without Manhattan rates, Pendry is worth a look; for guests who specifically want Williamsburg, McCarren is the more logical base.
Within Brooklyn, Ace Hotel Brooklyn is the most direct comparison. Ace holds its draw across all seasons through its lobby programming and food-and-beverage offer; McCarren's seasonal pool gives it a summer edge, but Ace is the better all-year pick if you are undecided on timing. The Ludlow Hotel on the Manhattan side offers a Lower East Side location with more dining and nightlife density immediately outside the door, worth considering if neighbourhood walkability at night matters more to you than a pool.
The honest read: McCarren is the right call in summer if the pool matters and you are comfortable with peak-season rates. Outside of summer, the value case depends on rate, check what Ace Hotel Brooklyn is charging for the same dates before committing. For guests who want the most from New York City's hotel scene, see our full New York City hotels guide for a broader comparison set including options like Crosby Street Hotel and The Greenwich Hotel.
Explore New York City
Save or rate McCarren Hotel & Pool on Pearl
Keep this venue in your Pearl passport, rate it after you visit, and track it alongside every other place you collect.