Gatsby’s

Gatsby’s in Warren is a classic American fine dining restaurant focused on steak and seafood. The details point to a dinner-service venue with a smart casual dress code, a price point of about $75 per person, a menu centered on prime grade steaks, seafood specialties, lamb chops, Wagyu beef from Carney’s Wagyu Cattle Ranch.

The confirmed recognition attached to Gatsby’s is the Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence in 2026. That accolade supports the restaurant’s positioning as a steak-and-seafood choice in Warren for diners planning an evening meal.

A classic steak-and-seafood restaurant with confirmed Wine Spectator recognition

The food lane is direct: classic American fine dining with steak and seafood at the center. Prime grade steaks, seafood specialties, lamb chops, Wagyu beef from Carney’s Wagyu Cattle Ranch are the signature dishes, so Gatsby’s makes the most sense for diners who want a traditional fine-dining dinner built around those categories.

First-timers should approach Gatsby’s as a Warren dinner choice for steak, seafood, lamb, or Wagyu rather than as a place defined by a more specific format not confirmed in the available details. The price is about $75 per person, the restaurant’s confirmed hours are Wednesday through Saturday from 5–10 PM. For a deeper Warren planning pass, the practical move is to scan Our full Warren restaurants guide before committing the whole evening here.

Because the hours are limited to evening service, Gatsby’s is best considered in advance rather than treated as an everyday all-hours option. It is closed Monday, Tuesday, Sunday, it is open Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday from 5–10 PM.

Plan for dinner, not lunch

The confirmed dress code is smart casual, which fits the restaurant’s fine-dining steak-and-seafood positioning. Gatsby’s is therefore a better match for diners who want a planned dinner in Warren than for anyone looking for lunch or a casual meal.

The practical details are simple: expect Wednesday-to-Saturday dinner hours, a $75-per-person price point, a menu anchored by classic American steak and seafood. Those facts make Gatsby’s easiest to evaluate as a planned evening meal.

For context beyond this one dinner choice, Warren coverage can help separate dinner, lodging, day planning: Our full Warren hotels guide, Our full Warren bars guide, Our full Warren wineries guide, Our full Warren experiences guide. Other dining in Warren can also be considered depending on the kind of evening you want.

Who should book, who should skip it

Book Gatsby’s if you want classic American fine dining in Warren with prime grade steaks, seafood specialties, lamb chops, Wagyu beef from Carney’s Wagyu Cattle Ranch, confirmed Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence recognition in 2026. Skip it if you need lunch, Sunday through Tuesday dining, or a lower-commitment meal outside the verified Wednesday-to-Saturday dinner window.