F&F Pizzeria

Is F&F; Pizzeria Worth Booking in 2025?

Yes, especially if you are the kind of eater who tracks Opinionated About Dining lists. F&F; Pizzeria on Court Street in Carroll Gardens has appeared on OAD's Cheap Eats in North America rankings three years running, moving from #69 in 2023 to #114 in 2024 to #166 in 2025. That downward trajectory in rank is worth noting, but the consistency of the recognition confirms this is not a one-season story. New York Magazine also named it among the 43 best restaurants in the city for 2025, which puts it in rare company for a neighborhood pizzeria.

The Pizza Case for Carroll Gardens

F&F; Pizzeria is the work of Frank Falcinelli and Frank Castronovo, the duo behind Frankies Spuntino, which has run a loyal following in Carroll Gardens for years. Their approach to pizza here leans into the kind of focused, ingredient-led cooking they have always favored: the emphasis is on quality inputs and restraint rather than novelty toppings or format experimentation. For a food-focused traveler or a New Yorker who follows this category closely, that context matters. This is not a gimmick operation. It is a serious pair of restaurateurs applying their track record to a pizza-specific format, which is exactly the kind of project that tends to hold up over time.

The OAD Cheap Eats designation also signals something practical: you are almost certainly not spending fine-dining money here. That makes F&F; a strong call for a weekday dinner before or after exploring Carroll Gardens, or as an anchor for a South Brooklyn eating day that might also include stops around our full New York City restaurants guide. If you are building a pizza-focused itinerary across boroughs, pair this with Leading Pizza in Williamsburg or Angelo's Coal Oven Pizza in Midtown for a legitimate cross-borough comparison.

When to Go

The optimal window for F&F; is a weekday evening or an early weekend dinner, before the Carroll Gardens neighborhood foot traffic peaks. Pizza this well-regarded draws a local crowd that fills rooms fast on Friday and Saturday nights. If your schedule allows, a Tuesday or Wednesday visit will give you a more relaxed experience and likely better table availability. Arriving early in the dinner service also means you are eating pizza at its freshest pull from the oven, which matters more than most people account for.

Seasonally, the late-fall and winter months tend to favor this kind of pizzeria visit: the room is warm, the format suits the weather, the neighborhood is quieter than summer. That said, a warm-weather visit to Carroll Gardens has its own appeal given the tree-lined streets, so timing this around a broader South Brooklyn afternoon is a reasonable approach in any season.

The Drinks Question

F&F; works best as the food centerpiece rather than a cocktail destination. What is consistent with the Frankies Spuntino model is a focused, Italian-leaning wine list: short, well-chosen, priced for a neighborhood crowd rather than a collector. If cocktails are your primary interest, F&F; is probably not the venue to anchor that decision on. Plan drinks elsewhere on the same evening and treat F&F; as the food centerpiece. For a broader view of where to drink nearby, our full New York City bars guide covers the current options across Brooklyn and Manhattan.

Practical Details

Reservations: Booking is easy, which means you should still book ahead rather than assume walk-in availability, particularly on weekends. Dress: Casual. This is a Carroll Gardens pizzeria, not a tasting menu room. Budget: OAD Cheap Eats classification puts this in the accessible range, likely under $30 per person for pizza and a drink. Getting there: Court Street in Carroll Gardens is accessible via the F and G trains. Groups: Check current booking channels directly for group availability.

How It Compares