Prime + Proper

In Nashville’s special-occasion dining lane, book Prime + Proper when the brief is a modern American steakhouse dinner rather than a low-key casual meal. The details point to a premium steakhouse experience with a $175 per person price point, smart casual dress, dinner service throughout the week.

The clearest reason to choose it is the steakhouse identity. Prime + Proper is not best framed as a broad, casual American restaurant; it is a modern American steakhouse with a menu anchored by signature dishes such as Whiskey-Aged Cowboy Ribeye, Proper Plateau, Chicken Fried Lobster, Tableside Dover Sole, Ora King Salmon, Dry Aged Steak Tartare.

A dressed-up steakhouse built around signature dishes

Prime + Proper sits in the modern American steakhouse category. That makes it a practical pick for a dinner where the group wants a clear steakhouse direction rather than an experimental or loosely defined meal. The listed signature dishes point to a menu with premium steakhouse markers, including Whiskey-Aged Cowboy Ribeye, Proper Plateau, Chicken Fried Lobster, Tableside Dover Sole, Ora King Salmon, Dry Aged Steak Tartare. For a first booking, the smarter move is to order into that core identity rather than treat it like a general American restaurant.

The price point is the deciding factor. At $175 per person, Prime + Proper should be reserved for a dinner where the group actually wants a premium steakhouse occasion. Smart casual dress is the baseline, which gives the meal a dressed-up feel without requiring formal attire. The restaurant is open for dinner daily, with hours listed as 5–10 PM Monday through Thursday, 4:30–11 PM Friday and Saturday, 5–10 PM Sunday.

Prime + Proper also has a confirmed Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence for 2026. That recognition is relevant for guests comparing upscale steakhouses, though the strongest case for booking remains the combination of modern American steakhouse cuisine, the $175 per person price point, the named signature dishes.

Who should book it, who should skip it

Book this for a celebratory dinner where a modern American steakhouse in Nashville is the right fit. Smart casual dress is the stated code, but the price point and menu make it easy to treat the reservation as a more polished night out.

Skip it if the group is price-sensitive, wants a spontaneous casual meal, or is looking for a lunch option. The hours point to dinner service only, the $175 per person price places it firmly in the premium-dinner category. Prime + Proper is better understood as a polished, steakhouse-led dinner rather than a casual stop.

For Nashville visitors building a broader trip, use Our full Nashville restaurants guide alongside Our full Nashville hotels guide if the dinner is tied to where the group is staying.