Craig’s

Should you book Craig's in West Hollywood?

Yes; if you want a proper American dinner in West Hollywood on a Tuesday night without a three-week wait. Craig's on Melrose Ave has been earning repeat business from a crowd that includes both industry regulars and neighborhood diners who know the room. It earned a spot on Opinionated About Dining's Leading Restaurants in North America in both 2023 (Recommended) and 2024 (Ranked #490), which tells you this is not a scene-only restaurant coasting on its zip code. Under chef Kursten Kizer, the kitchen is doing enough right to hold that credibility year after year.

The Room and When to Go

Craig's runs dinner seven nights a week: 5–11 pm Monday through Saturday, closing an hour earlier on Sunday at 10 pm. The energy here trends toward lively rather than quiet; this is a West Hollywood dining room, it sounds like one. If conversation matters to you, aim for an early seating closer to 5 or 6 pm, before the room fills and the ambient noise climbs. Later in the evening, the energy shifts toward the kind of table where you're leaning in to hear your companion. That's not a dealbreaker, but it's worth knowing before you plan a dinner where you need to actually talk.

If you've been once and liked it, the repeat visit case is direct: you already know the room works, the service held up, the kitchen delivered. The question for regulars is usually about sequencing the menu rather than whether to return at all.

How It Fits Into the LA American Dining Picture

Craig's sits in a distinct lane for Los Angeles American restaurants: dinner-only, West Hollywood, recognizable enough to attract a mixed crowd of industry and genuine food-focused diners. If you're comparing it against Jar, the other OAD-recognized American in the city, Craig's skews livelier and more social; Jar is quieter and leans harder into the steakhouse-adjacent category. For something more neighborhood and low-key, Agnes and Dear Jane's offer different registers of the American dinner format. Delilah overlaps in energy and neighborhood, but tilts much further toward the supper-club experience. Craig's sits between those poles.

For a morning or midday American option nearby, Breakfast by Salt's Cure is the sharpest daytime choice in the area. Craig's doesn't do lunch, the kitchen opens at 5 pm daily, so if you're planning a full day around Melrose, you'll want to plan accordingly.

Booking and Logistics

Booking difficulty at Craig's is rated Easy. You don't need to plan weeks out the way you would for a tasting-menu restaurant, the dinner-only format (opening at 5 pm each day) keeps the calendar simpler. For most nights, a few days' notice should be sufficient, though a Saturday reservation during a busy stretch of the LA social calendar warrants earlier action. Walk-ins may be possible early in the week, but don't rely on it if you have a specific night in mind.

Craig's is at 8826 Melrose Ave, West Hollywood, a well-trafficked stretch with parking options nearby, though street parking on Melrose itself can require patience depending on the night. If you're arriving from outside the neighborhood, build in time.

Is the OAD Recognition Worth Weighing?

The Opinionated About Dining recognition carries weight because it's driven by experienced diners rather than anonymous reviews, Craig's has held the citation across consecutive years. A ranking of #490 in North America in 2024 doesn't make it the leading American restaurant in Los Angeles, but it places it firmly in the tier of restaurants where the kitchen is doing something worth the trip. For context, OAD lists venues like Le Bernardin in New York City, The French Laundry in Napa, and Lazy Bear in San Francisco in the same program. Craig's is not operating at those price points or format levels, but the shared recognition signals that the food here is taken seriously by people who eat seriously.

For American dining comparisons further afield, Hilda and Jesse in San Francisco and Selby's in Atherton offer useful calibration points for the broader West Coast American dinner category. Chicago's Smyth and New Orleans' Emeril's round out the national frame. Craig's is a different format from all of them, but knowing where it sits in that landscape helps set expectations before you arrive.

Pearl Comparison: Craig's vs. Peers in Los Angeles

See our full Los Angeles restaurants guide, Los Angeles hotels guide, Los Angeles bars guide, Los Angeles wineries guide, and Los Angeles experiences guide for more.

Pearl Picks Nearby

• Jar, American, West Hollywood
• Delilah, Supper club, West Hollywood
• Agnes, American, Pasadena
• Dear Jane's, American, Los Angeles
• Breakfast by Salt's Cure, Daytime American, Los Angeles
• Holbox, Mexican Seafood, Los Angeles
• Single Thread Farm in Healdsburg, For a Northern California contrast