Matthew's
San Marco, Jacksonville
Restaurant in Jacksonville, United States
Book with PearlThe Read
Dress
Smart Casual
Why go
Matthew's is a better fit for a planned Jacksonville dinner than a casual drop-in meal. Book it for dates, anniversaries, client dinners, or any evening where a composed room matters; cross-shop bb's, Rue Saint Marc, or The Bearded Pig if the group wants something looser.
About Matthew's
Is Matthew's worth considering in Jacksonville? It is best treated as a planned dinner choice rather than a daytime stop: Matthew's is open from 4:30–10 PM Monday through Saturday and closed Sunday, with a smart casual dress code.
If you want another restaurant option, The Bearded Pig may be worth comparing. If the goal is a different restaurant option, bb's is another name to consider.
Book it for dinner, not for a casual daytime stop
Matthew's hours point clearly toward dinner: Matthew's opens at 4:30 PM and closes at 10 PM Monday through Saturday, it is closed Sunday. Lunch service is not offered, so plan around an evening meal.
The dress code is smart casual. First-timers should check current information directly before making detailed plans, as specific cuisine, menu format, signature dishes, pricing, service style, or seating details are not available.
Who should choose it over nearby options
Choose Matthew's when the dinner schedule and smart casual dress code fit the night you are planning. For other restaurant options to compare, you might also consider Rue Saint Marc, Toscana Little Italy, Fore Score San Marco, The Bearded Pig, or bb's.
For visitors comparing across the city, start with our full Jacksonville restaurants guide. Key details for Matthew's are direct: dinner hours Monday through Saturday from 4:30–10 PM, Sunday closure, smart casual dress.
Planning details
- Location
- 2107 Hendricks Ave, Jacksonville, FL 32207
- Reservations
- Book on OpenTable
- Website
- matthewsrestaurant.com
- Phone
- +19043969922
The take
The Take
The Vibe
Matthew's presents a quietly intense fine-dining experience that favors restraint over spectacle. The room leans warm and compressed, the kind of environment where lighting and acoustics are tuned to conversation rather than to flash. Rather than signaling seriousness through ceremony, the restaurant calibrates for composed comfort: white-tablecloth service and careful design choices keep the atmosphere refined without becoming rigid. Because it sits comfortably within San Marco's architecturally coherent streetscape, Matthew's reads as a neighborhood anchor—familiar to regulars yet formally attentive—making for an evening that feels both considered and welcoming.
Best For
Matthew's is primarily a dinner destination that suits diners seeking a composed, formal evening—think business dinners, date nights and milestone celebrations. The restaurant's placement in San Marco, a neighborhood described as 'dinner-serious,' and its long-standing role as a neighborhood anchor attract a steady clientele who return regularly. The room's measured atmosphere supports conversation and lingering over multiple courses, so it's best for groups and couples who value attentive service and a traditionally paced fine-dining experience rather than quick, casual meals.
Ordering Tips
Signature items signal the kitchen's direction: the Duck with parsnip purée and Tuna Tartare showcase composed, ingredient-driven plates, and the Chef's Tasting Menu is offered for those who want the fullest expression of the meal. Given the room's deliberate pacing and emphasis on a composed dining rhythm, opt for the tasting menu if you want a curated progression; otherwise pick one of the hallmark mains and allow the service to pace courses so conversation can flow between dishes.
Venue details
Ambiance
Refined yet relaxed atmosphere with attentive service, artfully plated dishes, and a quiet elegant dining room.
Tags
Vibe
Best For
Experience
Sourcing
At the Table
- Dress Code
- Smart Casual
- Noise Level
- Quiet
- Service Style
- Formal
- Meal Pacing
- Extended Experience
- Capacity
- Small
Signature Dishes
- Duck with parsnip puree
- Tuna Tartare
- Chef's Tasting Menu
Planning details
Location
2107 Hendricks Ave, Jacksonville, FL 32207 · Directions
Recognition and awards
Also consider
Where to go if you cannot get the right table
Try Rue Saint Marc for another polished Jacksonville dinner, or bb's if the group wants something more flexible. For a more casual fallback, The Bearded Pig is the better match.
Restaurant context
How Matthew's compares in Jacksonville
Matthew's is the pick when the dinner needs a more polished, occasion-ready feel. Rue Saint Marc is the closest cross-shop for a refined neighborhood meal, but it reads a little more flexible for regular dinners. Matthew's is the better call when the point of the night is the occasion itself.
For value and ease, bb's and Toscana Little Italy are safer choices for mixed groups, especially when not everyone wants a more formal dinner. The Bearded Pig is the obvious alternative for casual energy, bigger appetites, a lower-pressure night.
Fore Score San Marco works better when the activity matters more than the table. If the meal is the centerpiece, stay with Matthew's; if the group wants movement, noise, a more social setup, Fore Score San Marco is the cleaner fit.
Explore Jacksonville
Around this place
Discover more on Pearl
Unlock the full Matthew's guide in Pearl, including awards, comparisons, FAQs, planning details, and nearby places.
Compare Matthew's
| Venue | Location | Awards |
|---|---|---|
| Matthew's | Jacksonville | 2026 Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence |
| Rue Saint Marc | Jacksonville | No published awards |
| Fore Score San Marco | Jacksonville | No published awards |
| The Bearded Pig | Jacksonville | No published awards |
| bb's | Jacksonville | No published awards |
| Toscana Little Italy | Jacksonville | No published awards |
How Matthew's Jacksonville compares with similar nearby venues.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Matthew's good for a special occasion?
Matthew's may fit a planned dinner if its 4:30–10 PM Monday-through-Saturday hours and smart casual dress code match the occasion. Details like private dining, group policies, menu format, or pricing are not provided, so check directly before planning a specific event.
What should I wear to Matthew's?
The dress code is smart casual. Plan for neat dinner attire appropriate for an evening meal in Jacksonville.
Is Matthew's good for solo dining?
Solo dining is not specifically addressed. If the dinner hours and smart casual dress code suit your plans, Matthew's can be considered, but details such as bar seating or counter service are not confirmed.
Is lunch or dinner better at Matthew's?
Matthew's offers dinner. Matthew's is open 4:30–10 PM Monday through Saturday and closed Sunday; no lunch hours are offered.
What are alternatives to Matthew's in Jacksonville?
Other options to compare include Rue Saint Marc, Fore Score San Marco, The Bearded Pig, bb's, Toscana Little Italy. Matthew's features dinner hours Monday through Saturday and a smart casual dress code.
What should a first-timer know about Matthew's?
Plan for dinner, not lunch: Matthew's is open Monday through Saturday from 4:30–10 PM and closed Sunday. The dress code is smart casual. Specific claims about cuisine, prices, seating, service style, or signature dishes are not confirmed.
