Mastro's Steakhouse

Is Mastro’s Steakhouse in Columbus worth booking? Yes, if the goal is a fine dining steakhouse dinner with seafood and sushi options at a premium price point; skip it if you want a lower-cost or more casual meal. The basics are direct: Mastro’s Steakhouse is a Columbus steakhouse with seafood and sushi, business casual dress, evening hours, and a price of about $130 per person.

The clearest expectation to set is formality. This is not positioned as a casual drop-in meal; the dress code is business casual, and the menu is built around a premium steakhouse format. It is a natural fit for diners who want USDA Prime steaks with the option to add seafood, sushi selections, and richer sides or dessert.

A classic steakhouse order, widened by seafood and sushi

The strongest reason to book is the breadth of the menu within a formal steakhouse frame. USDA Prime steaks are the anchor, but the restaurant also includes seafood and sushi selections, which helps when not everyone at the table wants the same steakhouse order. For a first visit, a practical approach is to treat the meal as a shared table: steak for the center, seafood or sushi to start, and sides or dessert if the group wants a fuller occasion-dinner arc.

Named dishes give a useful read on the restaurant’s lane. Seafood Tower, Maguro Lime Roll, Lobster Mashed Potatoes, and Warm Butter Cake point toward a premium steakhouse experience with range beyond steak alone. That is a strength if the group includes mixed preferences. It is less compelling for diners chasing a casual meal or a lower price point. The venue is a better match for people who want a fine dining steakhouse with enough seafood and sushi to broaden the table.

Plan around dinner hours and the core menu

Mastro’s Steakhouse in Columbus is for evening service: Monday through Wednesday from 4–9 PM, Thursday through Saturday from 4–10 PM, and Sunday from 4–9 PM.

The better move is to build around the core categories that define the place: USDA Prime steaks, seafood, sushi selections, Lobster Mashed Potatoes, and Warm Butter Cake. If the group is split between lighter eating and a heavier steakhouse meal, the cuisine mix gives the table more flexibility than a steak-only format.

Who should book, and who should choose something else

Book if you want a business-casual, fine dining steakhouse in Columbus with seafood and sushi alongside USDA Prime steaks. The restaurant’s Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence recognition for 2026 is a confirmed external trust signal.

Do not book expecting a bargain meal or a casual neighborhood dinner. The appeal is the combination of steakhouse dining, seafood, sushi, a business casual setting, and a price point of about $130 per person. It is strongest for diners who want a fine dining steakhouse dinner and are comfortable with that spend.