American Pie

In Bridgehampton, American Pie is a casual American pizzeria with a direct, low-commitment profile. The details are simple: casual dress, a price of $20 per person, daily hours that run from 11:00 AM into the evening, with later closing on Friday and Saturday.

The useful read is this: treat it as a practical pizzeria option when the group wants something familiar and casual in Bridgehampton.

Use it for casual eating, not a destination dinner

The schedule is one of the clearest planning details. Sunday through Thursday, American Pie is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM; Friday and Saturday, it is open from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, as of July 2026. That later weekend close can make it a useful casual option when a group wants pizza in Bridgehampton without dressing up.

Safest way to read American Pie is as a direct casual pizzeria rather than a formal, chef-driven, or drinks-led dining plan.

Good value if expectations stay casual

American Pie works when value means casual dress, familiar pizzeria appeal, a $20-per-person price point. It is not necessary to build the decision around claims about awards, rankings, signature dishes, or service details; the confirmed facts already position it as an easygoing Bridgehampton pizzeria.

For a food-focused traveler, the decision is less about chasing novelty and more about reading the room correctly. If the night calls for a more composed meal or a different dining style, use our full Bridgehampton restaurants guide to plan another option. If the night calls for casual pizza in Bridgehampton, American Pie is the clearer fit.

Bridgehampton planning works better when food is matched to the rest of the trip. Pair this kind of low-key meal with broader local planning through our full Bridgehampton hotels guide, our full Bridgehampton bars guide, our full Bridgehampton wineries guide, our full Bridgehampton experiences guide.