Book with Pearl
Thanksgiving at Café Carmellini
A Thanksgiving Day three-course holiday prix-fixe menu at Café Carmellini in New York City.
Hotel2,780Points
The Fifth Avenue Hotel
Midtown South-Flatiron-Union Square, New York City
Hotel in New York City, United States
The Read
Gilded Age Revival Hospitality
Why go
The Fifth Avenue Hotel is a hotel in Manhattan's NoMad neighborhood.
About The Fifth Avenue Hotel
Against The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad and The Ned NoMad, The Fifth Avenue Hotel is a New York City option with notable hotel recognition and a smart casual dress code. The value case is not about claiming a specific rate or amenity set. It is about deciding whether its confirmed accolades and overall hotel positioning matter for your trip.
For 2026 planning, this is a New York City booking to consider if recognition is part of the brief. The Fifth Avenue Hotel has Michelin 2 Keys recognition from 2024, is listed as a Leading Hotels of the World member for 2025, appears on La Liste Top Hotels for 2026 with 92 points, is ranked #6 on Food & Wine's 2026 list of Top 10 US Hotels for Food and Drink, and appears at #75 on The World's 50 Best Hotels list for 2025. If the priority is a different kind of stay, compare it with Ace Hotel New York, The Ned NoMad, Hotel Seville NoMad - The Unbound Collection by Hyatt, or The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad.
A recognized New York City hotel with food-and-drink recognition
The clearest grounded reason to consider this property is its recognition profile. Food & Wine placing it at #6 among US hotels for food and drink in 2026 matters for travelers who care about a hotel being recognized in that category, while Michelin 2 Keys and other hotel accolades support its broader hotel positioning.
That does not make it the right pick for every trip. Travelers should compare it against Hotel Seville NoMad - The Unbound Collection by Hyatt, Ace Hotel New York, The Ned NoMad, and The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad before committing.
Who should book, and who should cross-shop
Book here if you want The Fifth Avenue Hotel specifically, and if its confirmed accolades are a meaningful part of the decision. It is less compelling if you do not care about hotel awards and recognition.
The comparison set is narrow but useful. NoMad, The Ned NoMad, Ace Hotel New York, Hotel Seville NoMad - The Unbound Collection by Hyatt, and The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad are relevant names to review. The Fifth Avenue Hotel sits in that set as a recognized New York City hotel with a smart casual dress code and multiple confirmed hotel accolades.
For broader New York City planning, compare it with Our full New York City hotels guide, then build the rest of the trip through Our full New York City restaurants guide and Our full New York City bars guide.
The takeThis is a hotel for travelers seeking top-tier, design-forward luxury in NoMad. With rates starting around $1,295 per night and recognition from multiple ranking bodies, the property suits special-occasion stays, well-heeled weekend escapes and business travelers who want a distinct Manhattan base away from Times Square. Its location between Flatiron and Midtown South also makes it convenient for guests who plan to move between Chelsea, the Village and Midtown. The hotel's pedigree and architecture appeal to guests who prize provenance, framed city context and a hotel experience that reads as both historic and current.
Venue detailsWifi
Know before you goBefore you book
Recognition and awards7 sources
Also considerAlternatives
Inside The Fifth Avenue Hotel
lobby_barThe Portrait BarRanked #93 on North America's Best Bars 2025, The Portrait Bar at 1 West 28th Street places itself in the Flatiron corridor where New York's craft cocktail culture has consolidated around technical programs and sourcing discipline. A Google rating of 4.5 from nearly 200 reviews signals consistent delivery against a demanding local comparable set. For visitors working through the city's serious bar scene, it belongs on any considered itinerary.
restaurantCafé CarmelliniHoused inside NoMad's Fifth Avenue Hotel, Café Carmellini is Andrew Carmellini's return to formal fine dining after more than a decade building a more casual portfolio. The room, designed by Martin Brudnizki, sets a Gilded Age register with double-height ceilings and jewel-toned banquettes. The menu moves between Italian and French traditions, anchored by signatures like Duck-Duck-Duck Tortellini and squab en croûte with foie gras.
Planning details
- Location
- 1 W 28th St, New York, NY 10001
- Website
- thefifthavenuehotel.com
- Phone
- +1 212-231-9400
Hotel contextNew York City, United States
Explore New York CityNearby
Around this placeMore Pearl picks
The take
The Take
The Vibe
The Fifth Avenue Hotel stages a deliberate architectural conversation: a 1907 Renaissance-style base that reads like a Gilded Age document is set against a 24-story glass tower, and the contrast defines the property's character. Inside, designer Martin Brudnizki's interventions are signaled as a counterpoint to Manhattan minimalism, making the hotel feel both anchored in history and deliberately contemporary. The result is a grand, classic hotel that leans on period detail and thoughtful design gestures rather than anonymity—an address that announces itself from the street and rewards guests who appreciate the interplay between preservation and modern hotel craft.
Best For
This is a hotel for travelers seeking top-tier, design-forward luxury in NoMad. With rates starting around $1,295 per night and recognition from multiple ranking bodies, the property suits special-occasion stays, well-heeled weekend escapes and business travelers who want a distinct Manhattan base away from Times Square. Its location between Flatiron and Midtown South also makes it convenient for guests who plan to move between Chelsea, the Village and Midtown. The hotel's pedigree and architecture appeal to guests who prize provenance, framed city context and a hotel experience that reads as both historic and current.
Stay Tips
Book early and expect premium pricing: the property is positioned in the upper tier of NoMad’s hotel market and lists rates from about $1,295 per night. Reservations are particularly important for high-demand dates and weekends, given the hotel's accolades and competitive peer set. If your trip is centered on dining or restaurant-focused exploration, plan ahead—NoMad is described as a food-serious corridor and the hotel carries industry recognition that signals a noteworthy hospitality program. Use the hotel's direct booking channels to confirm room type and any special requests tied to architecture-facing rooms or design-specific offerings.
Venue details
Ambiance
Sophisticated and elegant with dim lighting in the Portrait Bar, quiet soundproofed rooms, and an inviting atmosphere praised for warmth and detail-oriented service.
Tags
Vibe
ElegantSophisticatedWhimsical
Best For
Romantic GetawayBusiness TripWeekend Escape
Experience
TerraceHistoric BuildingDesign Destination
Amenities
WifiGymRoom Service
View
Street Scene
Accessibility
Wheelchair AccessibleElevator
About the Stay
- Rooms
- 153
- Check-in
- 15:00
- Check-out
- 11:00
- Property Type
- Boutique hotel
- Property Style
- Luxury Boutique in Historic Nomad Building
- Design Style
- Maximalist Eclectic with Custom Artwork and Jewel Box Opulence
- Airport Transfer
- Available
- Pets
- Allowed
- Families
- Welcome
- Cancellation
- Moderate
Know before you go
Know Before You Go
- Getting there
- 1 W 28th St, New York, NY 10001
Planning details
Location
Recognition and awards
Also consider
Where to look if it is not available
For a formal business stay nearby, try The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad. It is the safer choice when brand consistency matters more than a distinctive hotel personality.
For a more casual, rate-sensitive New York stay, try Ace Hotel New York or Hotel Seville NoMad - The Unbound Collection by Hyatt. Both are better fits when the hotel is mainly a base rather than a key part of the trip.
Hotel context
How it compares in NoMad
Choose The Fifth Avenue Hotel over Ace Hotel New York if the trip involves clients, a partner, or any situation where a more polished hotel matters. Ace is the easier value play for a casual stay; The Fifth Avenue Hotel is the stronger pick when the room, service environment, and food-and-drink credibility are part of the spend.
Against The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad, the decision is about predictability versus personality. The Ritz-Carlton is the safer corporate-luxury choice. The Fifth Avenue Hotel is better for travelers who want a less standardized stay without giving up serious recognition. Compared with The Ned NoMad, it reads less club-driven and more hotel-first, which can be better for work trips that need discretion.
NoMad remains the natural reference point for the neighborhood, while Hotel Seville NoMad - The Unbound Collection by Hyatt is the practical cross-shop if loyalty benefits or spend control matter. For a high-stakes New York stay, The Fifth Avenue Hotel is the stronger quality play; for a rate-sensitive trip, start with Hotel Seville or Ace.
Explore New York City
Around this place
Read more on Pearl
Discover more on Pearl
Unlock the full The Fifth Avenue Hotel guide in Pearl, including awards, comparisons, FAQs, planning details, and nearby places.
Compare The Fifth Avenue Hotel
| Venue | Location | Awards |
|---|---|---|
| The Fifth Avenue Hotel | New York City | 2026 Food & Wine Top 10 US Hotels for Food and Drink · #62026 World’s 50 Best Hotels 51-100 · #782026 Travel + Leisure 100 Favorite Hotels in the World · #82100 Most Incredible Hotels in the World · 2026Travel + Leisure T+L 500 Hotels 2026 Featured StandoutsLeading Hotels of the World 20262026 La Liste Top Hotels2026 Michelin 2 Keys2025 World’s 50 Best Hotels · #75 |
| NoMad | New York City | No published awards |
| The Ned NoMad | New York City | No published awards |
| Ace Hotel New York | New York City | No published awards |
| The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad | New York City | No published awards |
| Hotel Seville NoMad - The Unbound Collection by Hyatt | New York City | No published awards |
How The Fifth Avenue Hotel New York City compares with similar nearby venues.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the best time to book The Fifth Avenue Hotel?
Book when your New York City dates are firm, especially if The Fifth Avenue Hotel's confirmed recognition is a major reason for choosing it. Compare it with Ace Hotel New York and other New York City options if you are deciding among hotels.
How is the location of The Fifth Avenue Hotel?
The Fifth Avenue Hotel is in New York City. For comparison, consider The Ned NoMad, Hotel Seville NoMad - The Unbound Collection by Hyatt, and The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad if you are deciding among other New York City hotel options.
How does The Fifth Avenue Hotel compare to other hotels?
Choose this property if you want a New York City hotel with confirmed recognition, including Michelin 2 Keys in 2024 and a #6 placement on Food & Wine's 2026 list of Top 10 US Hotels for Food and Drink. The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad and Ace Hotel New York are among the other New York City hotels to review.
What is The Fifth Avenue Hotel known for?
The Fifth Avenue Hotel is known as a recognized New York City hotel, with confirmed accolades including Michelin 2 Keys, Leading Hotels of the World membership, La Liste Top Hotels recognition, Food & Wine recognition for food and drink, and a 2025 placement on The World's 50 Best Hotels list.
