The Dutch

The Dutch, SoHo: Worth Booking?

The Dutch earns a clear yes for SoHo dining — it holds up as a reliable, well-rounded American brasserie that works across multiple scenarios: a relaxed dinner with out-of-town guests, a late-evening meal when you want something more substantial than bar food, or a return visit after a first impression that left you curious. If you've been once and liked it, there's enough range on the menu to justify coming back with a different group or a different intention.

The Space

The room at 131 Sullivan St is built for comfort rather than spectacle. The layout divides well between the bar area and the dining room proper, which matters more than it sounds: if you're arriving after 9 PM, the bar end of the room holds energy without tipping into chaos, making it a practical choice for late-night meals when you want atmosphere without having to shout. The dining room side reads quieter, better for conversation. For a party of two, request a table rather than the bar if you're planning to eat seriously. Groups of four or more tend to fit naturally in the main room without feeling squeezed.

Late-Night at The Dutch

Where The Dutch earns particular credit is late-night viability. SoHo's options thin out considerably after 10 PM, and The Dutch consistently appears as one of the more dependable kitchens to stay open later in the neighbourhood. The American brasserie format — broad menu, full bar, no tasting-menu commitment, makes it practical when you want a real meal at an hour when most kitchens are winding down. The bar program supports a longer evening without the menu feeling like an afterthought. This is the scenario where The Dutch has a clearer advantage over peers: if you're deciding between an early sitting somewhere more ambitious and a later meal here, the later meal here often wins on ease and enjoyment. Check current hours directly before arriving late, as kitchen cutoff times vary.

If You've Already Been Once

For a return visit, shift focus toward the bar rather than replicating your first dinner. The cocktail list is where The Dutch shows more personality than the food alone might suggest, and it's a better anchor for an evening that starts with drinks and moves into eating. The American comfort-leaning menu means you're unlikely to hit a bad dish, but you're also not coming back for revelation, you're coming back because the room works, the service is steady, and the whole package holds together without requiring much planning. That's a legitimate reason to return.

Practical Details

Reservations: Easy to book; same-week availability is typically achievable, and walk-ins work well at the bar. Dress: Smart casual, SoHo-standard, no formality required. Budget: Mid-range for New York; expect a full dinner with drinks to land in the $70–$100 per person range, though this is an estimate based on comparable American brasseries in the neighbourhood rather than confirmed current pricing. Getting there: Sullivan St in SoHo places you within easy walking distance of Spring St on the C/E and Houston St on the 1. Leading timing: The sweet spot for late-night is 9:30–10:30 PM when the room has energy but hasn't tipped over. For a quieter dinner, aim for 6–7 PM.

How It Compares

See the full comparison below.

Explore More in New York City

• Our full New York City bars guide
• Our full New York City restaurants guide
• Our full New York City hotels guide
• Our full New York City wineries guide
• Our full New York City experiences guide

Pearl Picks Nearby

• Attaboy NYC, for serious cocktails in a quieter, conversation-friendly room
• Amor y Amargo, if you want a focused, bitters-led bar with real depth
• Angel's Share, the option for a more intimate, lower-key late evening
• Superbueno, a livelier alternative when energy matters more than quiet
• Bar Leather Apron in Honolulu, worth knowing if you're planning beyond New York
• Jewel of the South in New Orleans, the American brasserie-with-serious-bar comparison point
• Julep in Houston, for a different take on American late-night drinking culture