Prince Street Pizza

Do not come here expecting a polished sit-down pizzeria; the better read is a compact West Hollywood slice shop with New York and Sicilian-style pizza DNA. Prince Street Pizza is worth the stop when the decision is quick, loud, casual, slice-driven rather than a full dinner plan.

The room works like the format: a busy, high-traffic counter setup with a primarily grab-and-go feel and an energetic crowd of locals and visitors. It makes particular sense later in the day, especially on Friday and Saturday when hours run late enough to cover the post-midnight gap.

Square slices are the reason to go, not the room

The order should start with the Soho Square pepperoni Sicilian slice. That is the defining choice here and the clearest way to understand the appeal of this New York and Sicilian-style slice shop. Sicilian-style garlic bread is the add-on to consider, but this is not a broad Italian menu and should not be treated like one.

Value is strongest for solo diners, pairs, small groups who want a fast meal around the $20-per-person mark. The compact, counter-driven setup means it is better for a quick stop than a planned, lingering meal. For a longer West Hollywood dinner, look to other dining rooms in the area; for casual local browsing, compare it with other quick-service options around West Hollywood.

Go late, go casual, skip it for a polished meal

The main advantage is timing. Earlier visits may feel more direct, but dinner and late night are when the venue solves a real problem: fast, filling food in West Hollywood after standard dinner hours. Expectations matter more than ceremony. Dress does not need planning, the experience should be read as casual and counter-focused rather than hosted.

That matters because it keeps the recommendation narrow: go for the signature slice, the speed, the late hours. Do not go for ambience, chef-driven cooking, or a quiet table.

For broader planning around the area, Pearl’s West Hollywood restaurants guide and West Hollywood hotels guide are more useful than forcing this into a full-night itinerary. Readers comparing casual food can also think of Prince Street Pizza as a focused slice-shop stop rather than a full-service restaurant.

Quick reference: order the Soho Square, expect a compact counter setup, use it as a late-night slice stop rather than a full restaurant booking.