Skip to main content
    Food & Wine Classic in CharlestonNovember 13–15, 2026Pearl members: $500 off passes
    Pearl app wordmark

    Shelter Island, United States

    Restaurants in Shelter Island, United States

    Award sources that recognise some of these restaurants include Wine Spectator and Opinionated About Dining.

    Where to eat in Shelter Island

    Results

    5 places

    Léon 1909, Shelter Island, United States
    Restaurants

    Léon 1909

    Shelter Island, United States

    Léon 1909 is a strong Shelter Island pick for a date night or small celebration built around seasonal French-Italian…

    The Rams Head Inn, Shelter Island, United States
    Restaurants

    The Rams Head Inn

    Shelter Island, United States

    Choose The Rams Head Inn for a coastal American dinner that can become the whole evening: seafood, pasta, local…

    Vine Street Café, Shelter Island, United States
    Restaurants

    Vine Street Café

    Shelter Island, United States

    Vine Street Café is a strong Shelter Island pick when the group wants serious American cooking without a high-pressure…

    Marie Eiffel Market, Shelter Island, United States
    Restaurants

    Marie Eiffel Market

    Shelter Island, United States

    Marie Eiffel Market is a smart Shelter Island pick for a relaxed waterfront breakfast, brunch, or lunch when you want…

    How many places have you visited?

    Track restaurants, hotels, bars, and wineries you have already visited.