Where to eat in Shelter Island
Results
5 places

Restaurants
The Rams Head Inn
Shelter Island, United States
Choose The Rams Head Inn for a coastal American dinner that can become the whole evening: seafood, pasta, local…

Restaurants
The Terrace Restaurant
Shelter Island, United States
Book The Terrace Restaurant when the setting is part of the decision: waterfront Shelter Island dining, seasonal…

Restaurants
Vine Street Café
Shelter Island, United States
Vine Street Café is a strong Shelter Island pick when the group wants serious American cooking without a high-pressure…

Restaurants
Marie Eiffel Market
Shelter Island, United States
Marie Eiffel Market is a smart Shelter Island pick for a relaxed waterfront breakfast, brunch, or lunch when you want…
How many places have you visited?
Track restaurants, hotels, bars, and wineries you have already visited.

