Restaurant in San Diego, United States
Shelter Island Seafood Counter
Brigantine Point Loma is a mid-range waterfront seafood option on Shelter Island Drive with easy booking and a bar that runs later than most comparable San Diego rooms. It works best for spontaneous or late-evening visits rather than special-occasion dining. A practical, accessible choice when you want seafood near the water without the commitment of San Diego's harder-to-book venues.
Brigantine Point Loma on Shelter Island Drive is one of San Diego's more reliable waterfront seafood options for late-evening dining, where the bar stays active after the formal dinner crowd thins out. Pricing sits in the mid-range tier for the area, making it a more accessible call than splurge-level peers like Addison or Soichi, and the Shelter Island location means you are eating close to the water rather than inland. If you are planning a later evening out in San Diego and want a seafood-forward room without a difficult booking process, this is a reasonable pick.
The Brigantine name has been part of San Diego's dining fabric for decades, and the Point Loma location at 2725 Shelter Island Dr benefits from that accumulated familiarity. The draw here is direct: a seafood-focused menu in a waterfront-adjacent setting, with a bar program that runs later into the evening than many comparable spots. For the explorer who wants flavour context rather than just a table, the kitchen leans toward San Diego's coastal instincts — grilled fish, shellfish, and the kinds of preparations that prioritise the ingredient over elaborate technique.
The bar is worth noting separately. For late-night decisions in this part of the city, the Brigantine bar functions as a standalone option: order from a bar menu, hold a conversation, and avoid the more compressed timelines that come with formal dining rooms. If you are arriving after 9 PM and want more than a dive option but less than a formal tasting commitment, this format works. Compare that to 94th Aero Squadron or 777 G St for other late-leaning San Diego rooms with different positioning.
Booking is easy relative to the San Diego market. You are unlikely to need more than a few days of lead time for most evenings, which separates it sharply from harder-to-book venues like Addison. Walk-in capacity at the bar makes same-evening visits plausible. If spontaneity is part of your plan, Point Loma is one of the more forgiving waterfront options in the city for it.
For broader San Diego planning, see our full San Diego restaurants guide, our full San Diego bars guide, our full San Diego hotels guide, our full San Diego wineries guide, and our full San Diego experiences guide. If you are calibrating expectations against destination-level seafood at restaurants like Le Bernardin in New York City or tasting-format experiences like The French Laundry in Napa or Lazy Bear in San Francisco, Brigantine is operating in a different register: casual, accessible, neighbourhood-anchored rather than destination-driven. That is not a criticism — it is a clarification that keeps expectations honest.
Booking difficulty is low. A few days of lead time is typically enough for dinner reservations, and bar seating is generally available for walk-ins on most evenings. The Shelter Island Drive address puts you on the western edge of San Diego, convenient if you are based near Point Loma, Coronado, or the marina corridor, but a longer drive from downtown or Mission Hills. No dress code data is available, but the Shelter Island waterfront context suggests smart-casual is the practical ceiling. Check current hours directly with the venue before planning a late-night visit, as service windows can vary by season.
| Venue | Price | Booking Difficulty | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brigantine Point Loma | Easy | — | |
| Addison | $$$$ | Unknown | — |
| Callie | $$ | Unknown | — |
| Trust | $$$ | Unknown | — |
| Sushi Tadokoro | $$$ | Unknown | — |
| Soichi | $$$$ | Unknown | — |
Key differences to consider before you reserve.
Keep this venue in your Pearl passport, rate it after you visit, and track it alongside every other place you collect.
