Restaurant in New York City, United States · Inside The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad
Zaytinya
275Pearl PointsDinner First
About Zaytinya
Zaytinya is a practical NoMad pick for Mediterranean sharing, especially when dinner needs to run later than a standard early seating. Book it for mixed-preference groups, visiting friends, or a polished but not formal occasion; skip it if the night calls for a quiet tasting-menu format.
Is Zaytinya worth considering in New York City? Yes, if the goal is a Mediterranean meal with smart casual dress and broad daily hours. In a city where dining plans can vary widely, this is a useful option for a table that wants Mediterranean food in New York City.
The recent signal to pay attention to is recognition from Opinionated About Dining in 2025 and again in 2026, which puts it on the radar for diners who track casual restaurant recommendations. That makes it a clearer choice when the group wants Mediterranean cuisine in New York City and a smart-casual setting.
Late dinner is the strongest use case
The smart move is dinner, especially when the plan needs to stretch later than a standard early reservation. Zaytinya is open until 10:30 PM most nights and until 11 PM on Thursday, Friday, Saturday, so it can be easier to fit into an evening plan than restaurants with shorter hours. Use it when the table wants Mediterranean food in New York City and the timing needs some range.
Chef Michael Costa gives the restaurant a clear culinary lane, but the decision point is not chef worship. It is whether Mediterranean cuisine is the right fit for the group.
Who should pick it, who should not
Pick this for a meal that needs a smart-casual New York City restaurant with Mediterranean cooking and enough flexibility in the schedule to handle morning, daytime, or evening plans. It is less compelling for diners who are not looking for Mediterranean cuisine. The value is in adaptability: daytime meal, later dinner, visitor-friendly New York City choice, or a group that needs one booking everyone can agree on.
Dress should land in smart casual territory unless the rest of the evening calls for more. Quick reference: choose dinner for evening plans, use the listed daytime hours for convenience, look to the later evening hours when the group wants Mediterranean food in New York City.
Useful New York context before you decide
For another point of comparison, consider Dear Margo. If the group is not locked into one style of meal, a wider New York shortlist can help you compare other New York City dining rooms without forcing the meal into the same category. For broader planning, use Our full New York City restaurants guide, Our full New York City hotels guide, Our full New York City bars guide, Our full New York City wineries guide, Our full New York City experiences guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Zaytinya good for a special occasion?
Yes, if you want a Mediterranean meal in a smart-casual setting. The New York City restaurant has OAD recognition for 2025 and 2026, which gives it a clear point of distinction. It is a strong pick when the group wants Mediterranean food and flexible daily hours.
How far ahead should I book Zaytinya?
If you have a specific dinner time in mind, especially on a night when Zaytinya runs later, it is sensible to plan ahead. The verified hours extend to 10:30 PM most nights and to 11 PM on Thursday, Friday, Saturday. If your timing is flexible, use the posted hours to choose the part of the day that fits your plans.
Is lunch or dinner better at Zaytinya?
Dinner is the better bet for most people seeking an evening out, since the hours run through 10:30 PM most nights and later on Thursday, Friday, Saturday. The listed daytime hours can also work if you want a lower-friction meal in New York City, but dinner makes more sense for a later evening plan.
What should a first-timer know about Zaytinya?
Start with the fact that this is a Mediterranean restaurant in New York City, led by chef Michael Costa. The long daily hours make it easier to fit into a morning, daytime, or evening plan, which is useful if the group's timing is flexible. If the goal is Mediterranean food in a smart-casual setting, this is the right lane.
What should I wear to Zaytinya?
Aim for smart casual dress. Zaytinya is a Mediterranean restaurant in New York City, the verified dress code is smart casual. For dinner, polished basics are the safest choice.
What are alternatives to Zaytinya?
For other reference points, consider Dear Margo, The Bazaar, Sofra, Nomad Bar, Mamazul depending on the kind of meal the group wants. Use them as comparison points alongside Zaytinya rather than assuming they all serve the same purpose.
Does Zaytinya handle dietary restrictions?
Specific dietary-accommodation details are not verified here. If anyone in the group has allergies or dietary restrictions, contact Zaytinya directly before booking or note the restrictions when making the reservation.
Location
1185 Broadway Ground Floor, New York, NY 10001
New York City, United States
Compare Zaytinya
| Venue | Location | Cuisine | Awards |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zaytinya | New York City | Mediterranean | Opinionated About Dining Casual in North America Recommended (2026); Opinionated About Dining Casual in North America (2025) |
| The Bazaar | New York City | , | , |
| Mamazul | New York City | , | , |
| Nomad Bar | New York City | New American | , |
| Dear Margo | New York City | Mediterranean | , |
| Sofra | Cambridge | Mediterranean | , |
How Zaytinya NYC compares with similar nearby venues.
Where to book if this does not fit
Book Dear Margo if Mediterranean is non-negotiable but the group wants a different New York room. Choose Nomad Bar if the night is more about cocktails, bar energy, New American food than a shared Mediterranean dinner.
How it compares for Mediterranean and late-night-ish New York plans
Compared with The Bazaar, Zaytinya is the easier recommendation when the table wants Mediterranean range without making the meal feel like a production. The Bazaar is the better fit for diners chasing a bigger-deal night; Zaytinya is better for groups that care more about flexibility, later dinner utility, a less formal rhythm.
Dear Margo and Sofra are the more direct Mediterranean cross-shops. Choose Zaytinya when NoMad location and broad group appeal matter; choose Dear Margo when the plan is specifically Mediterranean but the group wants a different room and neighborhood feel. Sofra is out-of-metro, so it is not a like-for-like Manhattan substitute, but it works as a reference point for diners comparing Mediterranean meals across cities.
Nomad Bar is the better choice when drinks and New American bar food are the center of the night. Mamazul is a stronger pivot if the group wants a different cuisine mood entirely. For ease of booking, Zaytinya has the advantage: it is listed as easy, which makes it more useful for practical New York planning than venues that require tighter reservation strategy.
Recognized By
Save or rate Zaytinya on Pearl
Keep this venue in your Pearl passport, rate it after you visit, and track it alongside every other place you collect.