Four Twenty Five

Pearl Verdict

Four Twenty Five is the right call for any food-focused visitor who wants to eat seriously well in Midtown without the rigidity of a tasting-menu-only format. The dual-chef model of Jonathan Benno and Jean-Georges Vongerichten produces a menu that genuinely earns its fine-dining price point, the Park Avenue setting delivers a room that feels appropriate for both a business dinner and a celebratory night out. Book it if the combination of a globally-inflected menu, strong wine credentials, a physically impressive space matters to you. If you want a single-chef vision with a more focused culinary throughline, consider Le Bernardin or Atomix instead.

Portrait

Four Twenty Five occupies a particular niche in New York's dining map that most Midtown restaurants fail to fill: a room that reads as genuinely glamorous without tipping into self-parody. The building at 425 Park Avenue is glassy and modern, the restaurant leans into it, with an interior that draws comparisons to a 1930s ocean liner in terms of energy and polish. Natural light floods the space during the day, making it one of the more atmospheric lunch options in the corridor between Grand Central and the 50s. By evening, the room tightens into something more formal, the ambient feel shifts accordingly; composed rather than loud, suited to a conversation you actually want to have.

The kitchen is a collaboration between Jonathan Benno, who built his reputation at Per Se and Lincoln, Jean-Georges Vongerichten, one of the more recognisable names in American fine dining. The pairing is not merely cosmetic. Benno brings a classical, restraint-forward sensibility; Vongerichten contributes a willingness to pull flavour references from Italy, France, across Asia without losing coherence. The menu hopscotches between those influences in a way that, according to New York Magazine's three-star review, seduces rather than confuses. The result is an a la carte format that gives diners genuine choice, which is increasingly rare at this price tier in New York.

Dishes cited in published reviews include butter-poached lobster with a black pepper and ginger jus, handmade agnolotti with winter squash, amaretti and brown butter, a foie gras course plated alongside blood orange compote and warm, spiced madeleines. A chocolate tart finished with black cardamom crémeux, tonka whipped ganache, buckwheat caramel has been noted as a standout conclusion. These are not novelty dishes; they are carefully constructed plates that reflect the classical training both chefs bring to the room.

As a Park Avenue address, Four Twenty Five functions as a neighbourhood anchor for a stretch of Manhattan that has long needed a flagship dining option worthy of its density of corporate headquarters, luxury residential towers, hotel properties. For anyone staying in the area or arriving via Grand Central, it removes the need to travel downtown for a meal at this level. That convenience is worth factoring into your decision if you are building an itinerary around Midtown. For a broader view of where Four Twenty Five sits in the city's dining options, see our full New York City restaurants guide.

Awards & Recognition

• New York Times: Three stars
• New York Magazine: Listed among the 43 Best Restaurants in New York (2025)
• Esquire: Leading New Restaurants, ranked #21 (2024)
• Star Wine List recognition (2026)

Ratings

4.5 out of 5 (191 reviews). The Star Wine List recognition signals a wine program with genuine depth, which is relevant if you are planning to pair seriously across multiple courses.

Booking & Practical Details

Booking at Four Twenty Five is rated Easy relative to its peer set in New York City fine dining. That said, for Friday and Saturday evenings, lead time of two to three weeks is advisable. Prime-time slots during the week may move faster given the corporate and hotel clientele the address attracts. Reservations: Book in advance; walk-ins are unlikely at this level but may be possible at the bar. Dress: Smart casual at minimum; the room skews business formal in the evening. Budget: The venue does not publish a price range in available data, but the format, address, peer comparisons place it firmly in the $$$$ tier, expect comparable spend to other top-tier contemporary fine dining in New York. Location: 425 Park Ave, New York, NY 10022. Well-served by Grand Central and multiple subway lines on the East Side. For hotels close to this area, see our New York City hotels guide. For bars worth pairing with an evening here, see our New York City bars guide.

How It Compares

Against Le Bernardin and Per Se, Four Twenty Five offers a more flexible format: the a la carte menu means you are not committed to a multi-hour tasting structure. Per Se is a fixed tasting menu at a significantly higher price floor and remains harder to book. Le Bernardin is more focused in scope, seafood-only, French-trained, may be the stronger choice if you want a single-subject kitchen operating at its ceiling. Four Twenty Five wins on flexibility and room energy if neither of those trade-offs matters to you.

Against Atomix and Eleven Madison Park, the comparison shifts to format and philosophy. Both Atomix and EMP are tasting-menu-only and demand a full evening commitment. Four Twenty Five is the better choice for a diner who wants serious cooking without surrendering control of the evening's pace. Masa sits in a different category entirely, omakase sushi at the top of its price tier, is not a like-for-like comparison unless Japanese cuisine is your priority.

In the broader context of ambitious American fine dining, Four Twenty Five compares well to venues like Smyth in Chicago or Providence in Los Angeles in terms of positioning: serious cooking, identifiable chef credentials, a room that supports the price point without alienating guests who are not industry insiders. If you are eating across cities and tracking this tier, it holds its own. For other reference points in the category globally, The French Laundry in Napa and Single Thread Farm in Healdsburg represent the West Coast equivalent in format ambition, though both are tasting-menu-only.

Pearl Picks Nearby

• Full New York City restaurant guide
• New York City hotels
• New York City bars
• New York City wineries
• New York City experiences