
Barbuto Thanksgiving! at Barbuto
A Thanksgiving Day meal at Barbuto in New York City, featuring classic dishes by Chef Jonathan Waxman.

New American, Italian · West Village, New York City
Restaurant in New York City, United States
California Roots, New York Table
Price
$50–100per person
Dress
Casual
Why go
Barbuto is worth booking for a relaxed West Village occasion when the group wants New American and Italian food with credible New York recognition. Choose it over louder or more casual nearby options when dinner needs to feel considered, but not formal.
For a New York City meal built around New American and Italian cooking, Barbuto is a direct option to consider. It serves lunch and dinner daily, has a casual dress code, and has New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City recognition for 2025.
The main reason to keep Barbuto on the shortlist is that combination of cuisine and recognition. That does not mean it is the right choice for every plan. If you are comparing different New York City dining plans, STK Steakhouse is one option to consider. If the plan is more casual, The Standard Biergarten is another option to compare.
Barbuto is a casual New York City restaurant for New American and Italian food, rather than a formal or highly structured dining commitment. Its New American and Italian focus gives mixed groups a broad lane without requiring a more specific menu promise.
Timing matters because Barbuto serves both lunch and dinner. Lunch runs from 12 PM to 3:30 PM Monday through Friday and from 12 PM to 3 PM Saturday and Sunday. Dinner runs from 5 PM to 10 PM Sunday through Thursday, and from 5 PM to 11 PM Friday and Saturday.
Against Santina, Barbuto is the choice to consider when the plan centers on a New American and Italian restaurant with current New York Times recognition. Old Rose is another option to compare if the group wants a different kind of New York City dining plan.
The Mary Lane is a useful cross-shop for diners considering another New York City option. Barbuto is the more direct pick when the table specifically wants the New American and Italian combination and the 2025 New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City mention.
Reservations: plan around the lunch and dinner hours rather than assuming every time of day is available. Dress: casual. Solo dining: the lunch and dinner schedule makes either meal possible. Occasion fit: strongest when the goal is a casual New York City meal centered on New American and Italian cooking.
Barbuto reads as a classic, neighborhood restaurant that channels an older lineage of American farm-to-table cooking. Jonathan Waxman’s connection to Chez Panisse anchors the place in a disciplined, produce-first tradition; it has lineage and restraint. The food is Italian-accented and functional rather than theatrical, so the restaurant feels enduring and quietly assured. You won’t find culinary pyrotechnics here: what you do find is focused, ingredient-driven cooking that leans on familiarity and craftsmanship, making Barbuto feel like a dependable West Village mainstay rather than a fashionable experiment.
Barbuto suits diners looking for straightforward, seasonal Italian-accented plates: especially at dinner, when the signature roast chicken, gnocchi and vegetable-led offerings make the restaurant sing. Its production-led ethos and approachable preparations work well for date nights that prize food over theatrics, casual gatherings with friends, and small group dinners. The restaurant is best experienced as a place to sit, order a few thoughtful dishes to share, and enjoy honest, well-executed cooking rooted in a Californian farm ethic.
Order with the menu’s simplicity in mind: the roast chicken with salsa verde is a signature for a reason, and the kale salad and gnocchi are specifically called out as standout dishes. Given the produce-led approach, expect seasonal preparations; let the kitchen’s classic choices guide you rather than hunting for gimmicks. If you’re in a group, plan to share those highlighted dishes so everyone can sample the core expressions of the kitchen.
Bustling open kitchen with concrete floors, brick walls, and breezy glass garage doors creating a relaxed yet energetic industrial neighborhood vibe with natural light.
Barbuto is the better pick than The Standard Biergarten when the meal matters more than the hangout. The Standard Biergarten is easier for casual groups and drinks-led plans; Barbuto is stronger for dates, birthdays, and dinners where food credibility is part of the reason to go.
Compared with Santina, Barbuto is the safer choice for a New American and Italian dinner with broader group appeal. Santina makes sense when the group specifically wants Italian and a lighter downtown plan. Barbuto is better when the booking needs to feel more like a proper restaurant decision.
Choose STK Steakhouse for a louder steakhouse night, Old Rose for a softer hotel-adjacent meal, and The Mary Lane for a quieter New American alternative. Barbuto sits in the middle: easier to use for mixed groups than a steakhouse, more occasion-ready than a casual drinks venue, and backed by current New York Times recognition.
Unlock the full Barbuto guide in Pearl, including awards, comparisons, FAQs, planning details, and nearby places.
| Venue | Location | Cuisine | Awards |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barbuto | New York City | New American, Italian | 2025 New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City |
| Old Rose | New York City | No published awards | |
| Santina | New York City | Italian | No published awards |
| STK Steakhouse | New York City | No published awards | |
| The Standard Biergarten | New York City | No published awards | |
| The Mary Lane | New York City | No published awards |
How Barbuto NYC compares with similar nearby venues.
Use the lunch and dinner hours to plan: Barbuto serves lunch and dinner daily, with dinner until 11 PM on Friday and Saturday and until 10 PM the rest of the week. Old Rose is another New York City option to compare if you are keeping plans flexible.
Barbuto can be considered for a solo New American and Italian meal in New York City. The schedule includes both lunch and dinner service, so choose the time that best fits your plan.
Both lunch and dinner are offered. Lunch runs from 12 PM to 3:30 PM Monday through Friday and from 12 PM to 3 PM Saturday and Sunday. Dinner runs from 5 PM to 10 PM Sunday through Thursday, and from 5 PM to 11 PM Friday and Saturday. Compared with Santina, Barbuto is the better fit when you specifically want New American and Italian cooking with New York Times recognition.
Santina and Old Rose are New York City dining choices to compare. The Mary Lane, STK Steakhouse, and The Standard Biergarten are also worth considering depending on your group’s plans.
Barbuto serves New American and Italian food in New York City, with lunch and dinner service daily. If you want a more casual backup, The Standard Biergarten is another option to consider.
Yes, if the occasion calls for a casual New York City restaurant serving New American and Italian food. Barbuto has a 2025 New York Times Best Restaurants in New York City mention, which adds a notable recognition point. If you want to compare another New York City option, Santina is worth considering.
Expect New American and Italian food in New York City, with a casual dress code and both lunch and dinner service. Friday and Saturday dinner run until 11 PM; other dinners run until 10 PM.
Pearl events
Public events currently associated with this Pearl venue.

A Thanksgiving Day meal at Barbuto in New York City, featuring classic dishes by Chef Jonathan Waxman.
BarbettaNew York CityBarbetta's main argument is its wine cellar: 2,160 Italian selections with inventory running to 11,655 bottles, strong…
BarbouniaNew York CityCompared with Gramercy Tavern and Craft, Barbounia is the easier, wine-led choice for a repeat dinner near Flatiron…
BarbutoNew York CityAn all-day Italian restaurant in Brooklyn Bridge Park operating from 7 AM to 10:30 PM on weekends, convenient…
BarDoughNew York CityBarDough is a practical Midtown West pick when timing and Theater District location matter more than a highly…
Del Frisco's Double Eagle SteakhouseNew York CityDel Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse on Avenue of the Americas is a large-format Midtown steakhouse that earns…
Chim ChimNew York CityChim Chim is a practical pick when the night calls for Thai pastries and desserts rather than another full dinner…
Bar VeloceNew York CityBar Veloce is worth choosing for a casual East Village wine-bar plan: low-pressure, group-friendly in small numbers…
BarbèsNew York CityBarbès in Park Slope, Brooklyn is an easy first visit: low door price, a spirit-forward drink program, and a room…
BarChef New YorkNew York CityBook BarChef New York for a theatrical cocktail occasion, not for dinner.
Barely DisfiguredNew York CityBarely Disfigured is a sensible Smith Street pick for a date, small celebration, or flexible Brooklyn drinks plan.
Weather UpNew York CityWeather Up is a practical Prospect Heights cocktail stop, better for an easy drinks-led night than a serious food…
Arlo WilliamsburgNew York CityArlo Williamsburg is a strong pick if your priority is being close to North Williamsburg's restaurant and bar scene…
Baccarat Hotel New YorkNew York CityBaccarat Hotel New York is a hotel on West 53rd Street in Midtown Manhattan.
Boom Boom RoomNew York CityBoom Boom Room at The Standard, High Line is a late-night penthouse venue in Manhattan's Meatpacking District, known…
Casa Cipriani New YorkNew York CityCasa Cipriani New York is the downtown splurge to choose when privacy, atmosphere, and Lower Manhattan access matter…
ModernHaus SoHoNew York CityModernHaus SoHo is worth booking if the trip is centered on downtown New York and the address matters…
AtomixNew York CityAtomix is a Korean tasting-menu restaurant in New York City.
Jungsik New YorkNew York CityJungsik New York is a restaurant on Harrison Street in New York City.
KabawaNew York CityKabawa is Paul Carmichael and Momofuku's Caribbean restaurant in New York City.
DanielNew York CityDaniel is an Upper East Side restaurant for a formal French dinner, with prix-fixe and tasting menus in the main dining room. Its Lalique-designed bar and lounge offer shorter menus and cocktails in a different setting.
Gramercy TavernNew York CityGramercy Tavern is Danny Meyer's restaurant in New York's Flatiron District, serving seasonal American cuisine.