Ayat

Should You Book Ayat?

If you are comparing Ayat to the Palestinian and Middle Eastern spots closer to Manhattan, like Al Badawi in Bay Ridge or Kubeh downtown, the case for making the trip to Staten Island comes down to one thing: Ayat delivers Michelin-recognised Palestinian cooking at a $$ price point, in a neighbourhood room that feels completely unperformed. That is a rare combination in New York City, it is worth the commute for the right diner.

Ayat earned a Michelin Plate in 2024, which in practical terms means Michelin's inspectors found the cooking here to be genuinely good, distinct, consistent enough to single out. At the $$ price tier, that recognition carries real weight. You are not paying fine-dining prices for the credential; you are getting it as a bonus on top of an already accessible bill.

The Space

The room at Ayat, on a busy stretch of Hylan Boulevard, is honest about what it is. A glass façade dressed with vines and strung lights marks it out from its neighbours before you step inside. Inside, the space is compact and tidily kept, with murals covering the walls and a long counter that gives you a direct sightline to the kitchen. That counter is where the action is: flatbreads are shaped and cooked on a dome-shaped saj in front of you, shawarmas rotate on a spit nearby. The setup is practical and purposeful rather than designed for atmosphere, but the result is that the cooking becomes the room's main event. For a food-focused diner, that is exactly the right priority.

The neighbourhood feel here is genuine, not curated. This is a small, community-rooted spot opened by Abdul Elenani and his wife Ayat Masoud, after whom the restaurant is named. The pride in the cooking is visible in the details: the care taken with a saj flatbread, the way the shawarma is finished and plated. It reads as a place that does not need to perform its authenticity because it simply has it.

The Food

Menu is Palestinian, with the classics represented across the mezze selection and mains. Baba ghanoush features, beef shawarma is served over fluffy rice with tahini, the flatbreads from the saj counter are a focal point. This is the kind of cooking that is easy to underestimate from a distance and difficult to fault once you are eating it. The technical care in the flatbread alone, a product that rewards close attention to dough, heat, timing, signals a kitchen that takes its craft seriously.

For context on the broader Middle Eastern dining category in New York, Mamoun's and Mesiba occupy different positions in the city's offering. Mamoun's is faster and more casual; Mesiba skews toward Israeli-inflected celebration dining. Ayat sits in its own lane: Palestinian-specific, Michelin-noted, priced for regulars rather than occasion spending. If you want a point of international comparison, similar community-anchored Palestinian and Levantine cooking shows up at places like Bait Maryam in Dubai and Baron in Doha, where the category commands far more dining-out attention than it typically receives in the United States.

Practical Details

Ayat is at 2018 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10306. The price tier is $$, making it one of the more accessible Michelin-recognised Middle Eastern options in New York City. Going slightly off-peak, or earlier in the evening, reduces any wait. Phone and website details are not currently available through Pearl, so check Google or walk in directly. For more on dining across the five boroughs, see our full New York City restaurants guide.

If you are building a longer trip around New York's food scene, our full New York City bars guide, hotels guide, and experiences guide cover the rest of the city. For comparable neighbourhood-anchored seafood done with similar integrity, Astoria Seafood is worth knowing about in Queens. And for those travelling further afield, the standard of casual excellence Ayat represents is something you also find at places like Emeril's in New Orleans or Lazy Bear in San Francisco, though those operate at different price points entirely.

Quick reference:

For more across the city's Middle Eastern and broader dining scene, see our full New York City restaurants guide and our New York City wineries guide. Those planning a longer US food itinerary might also consider Alinea in Chicago, Single Thread Farm in Healdsburg, The French Laundry in Napa, or Providence in Los Angeles for contrast across the country's leading tables.