The Montauket

At about $40 per person, The Montauket is a casual Montauk option for American and seafood-bar cooking. The basics are direct: casual dress, bar and kitchen open seven days, a menu direction that includes lobster roll, local fish, burgers. Choose it when the priority is a relaxed meal rather than a formal dining-room experience.

The Montauket’s appeal is its simple positioning: Casual American & Seafood Bar in Montauk at a moderate per-person spend. It is a practical fit for groups with mixed preferences because the signature dishes cover seafood and burgers without requiring a more formal plan.

Go for lobster rolls, local fish, a casual seafood-bar meal

The clearest order here is the grounded one: lobster roll, local fish, burgers. Those dishes define what is known about the venue better than any broader claim about a changing menu or a chef-driven format. Set expectations around familiar casual American and seafood-bar cooking.

That makes The Montauket easier to understand as a direct Montauk stop: casual dress, moderate spend, recognizable dishes. If your group wants seafood but also needs a non-seafood option, the burger gives the table a simple fallback.

The planning logic is easy, but timing matters

The hours are useful for planning. The bar and kitchen are open seven days, with service from 2:00 PM Tuesday through Thursday and from 12:00 Noon Friday through Monday. Use those start times when deciding whether The Montauket fits your afternoon or evening plans.

Dress code is casual, the listed price is about $40 per person. Beyond those facts, avoid over-planning around assumptions about seating, reservations, or special service formats; treat it as a casual Montauk American and seafood-bar option and confirm current details directly if they matter for your visit.

Who should choose it

Choose it if the table wants a relaxed Casual American & Seafood Bar in Montauk with a verified $40 per person price point and familiar dishes like lobster roll, local fish, burgers. For broader planning, use our full Montauk restaurants guide for other dining options, then check our full Montauk bars guide if the plan is more casual. Travelers staying over can pair it with our full Montauk hotels guide, while activity-led trips should start with our full Montauk experiences guide.