Blackbird Pizza Shop

The Verdict

If you have been to Blackbird Pizza Shop once and found the New York-style slices worth the trip to Long Beach, a return visit will confirm what you suspected: the consistency here is the draw. Joshua Skenes, better known for wood-fire fine dining at the highest level, brings that same ingredient-focused discipline to a pizza counter at 3405 Orange Ave. For a special occasion that does not require a white tablecloth, or a date night that prioritises quality over ceremony, Blackbird is a genuine option in a city where pizza ambition is more common than pizza execution.

What to Expect

The setting reads immediately as intentional rather than accidental. This is not a slice counter dressed up as a restaurant, nor a fine-dining room that happens to serve pizza. The visual cues are spare and direct: the kind of room where the product is clearly the point. For a date or a low-key celebration, that restraint works in your favour. There is no performance to get through before the food arrives.

The New York-style format means the pizza is the anchor, but the drinks program deserves attention as a standalone consideration. In Los Angeles, where bar programs at casual venues are often an afterthought, a well-considered drink list can shift how a meal sits. If you are planning a celebratory visit, check what is on offer before you arrive. The right pairing lifts a good slice into a full evening rather than a quick stop.

For context on what Skenes brings to this format: his background in high-precision cooking, most associated with wood-fire technique, is the kind of culinary credential that rarely shows up at a pizza shop price point. That gap between pedigree and price is where Blackbird earns its recommendation. You are not paying for the name.

Booking here is direct compared to the tightly held reservation windows at venues like Kato or Somni. If you are planning a group dinner or a date night in the Long Beach area, Blackbird does not require the same advance planning as the city's more sought-after tables. That accessibility is part of its value proposition.

For a different style of special-occasion pizza in Los Angeles, Apollonia's Pizzeria offers a contrasting experience worth considering. And if New York-style pizza is the format you want to benchmark against its home city roots, Roberta's Pizza in New York City remains the reference point for what the format can do at its most ambitious.

Explore more of what the city offers through our full Los Angeles restaurants guide, our full Los Angeles bars guide, and our full Los Angeles experiences guide. If you are visiting from out of town, our full Los Angeles hotels guide covers where to stay.

How It Compares

Blackbird Pizza Shop sits in a different category from most of the Pearl-recommended venues in greater Los Angeles, that is the point. If you are choosing between Blackbird and Kato, Hayato, or Sushi Kaneyoshi, the decision is not really about quality; it is about format and commitment. Those venues run at $$$$ price points with tasting menus and weeks-long booking waits. Blackbird is accessible, casual, easy to get into. If you want a special meal without a special occasion protocol, Blackbird wins on friction alone.

Against Vespertine, which is the most experiential and demanding option in the Los Angeles comparison set, Blackbird is the opposite proposition: no theatrics, no elaborate format, no lengthy commitment of time or money. Vespertine is worth booking if the immersive dining format is what you are after. Blackbird is worth booking when the meal itself is the point. For value-to-quality comparison, Holbox at $$ is the closest peer in terms of price accessibility and chef-driven ambition at a casual register, though the cuisine formats are entirely different.

Within the pizza category specifically, Blackbird occupies a position that few Los Angeles venues can match: a high-pedigree chef applying serious technique to a format priced for regular visits. If you are benchmarking against the broader Pearl restaurant set in California, venues like Single Thread Farm in Healdsburg and The French Laundry in Napa represent the upper ceiling of the state's dining ambition. Blackbird is not competing there, nor does it need to. It is the answer to a different question: where do you go in Long Beach when you want something genuinely considered without the full fine-dining overhead?