The Reform Club
Amagansett
Hotel in Amagansett, United States
Book with PearlWhy go
The Reform Club works for a quieter Amagansett stay where privacy and a composed setting matter more than a resort-style amenity checklist. Recent 2026 recognition from Tablet Hotels and Vogue adds confidence, but value-seekers should cross-shop carefully if pool, spa, or dining details are central to the trip.
About The Reform Club
For return Hamptons visitors, the useful question is not whether Amagansett is quieter than East Hampton; it is whether staying here gives enough calm and convenience to justify choosing it again. The Reform Club is a good fit if the point of the trip is space, privacy, a slower base near the village rather than a resort-style checklist. Its 2026 recognition from Tablet Hotels and Vogue gives it a credible quality signal in a crowded Hamptons hotel field, but the booking case is still practical: choose it for a composed stay, not for a heavily programmed property.
A calm Amagansett base for travelers who value breathing room
The address on Windmill Lane puts the hotel in Amagansett, which suits guests who want the East End without making every plan revolve around East Hampton. For value-seekers, that matters: the trade is less about chasing amenities and more about paying for a quieter setting that can make a short stay feel less compressed. If pool, spa, wellness amenities are the deciding factor, compare closely before committing, because the available venue details do not support booking this purely as a spa-led escape.
The stronger use case is a couple’s weekend, a low-key reset, or a return trip where the beach, town, downtime matter more than a see-and-be-seen lobby. Families may also find Amagansett easier to manage than busier East Hampton, but the fit depends on room configuration and service needs, which should be checked before locking plans.
Who should book, who should cross-shop
Book here if easy logistics, a quieter Hamptons base, recent hotel recognition carry more weight than a long amenity list. Cross-shop The Roundtree Amagansett if the decision is mainly about staying within Amagansett, use our full Amagansett hotels guide to compare the broader set. If dining or drinks will drive the trip, also check our Amagansett restaurants guide and our Amagansett bars guide before choosing the hotel.
Planning details
- Location
- 23 Windmill Lane
- Website
- reformclubamagansett.com
- Phone
- 631 267 8500
Planning details
Location
Recognition and awards
Also consider
Also Consider
- The Roundtree Amagansett, Notable alternative
- Journey East Hampton, Notable alternative
- The Baker House 1650, Notable alternative
- The Maidstone, Notable alternative
- EHP Resort & Marina (East Hampton), Notable alternative
Hotel context
How It Compares
The Roundtree Amagansett is the cleanest comparison because it keeps the decision inside Amagansett. Choose The Reform Club if recent hotel recognition and a quieter-feeling base are the priority; choose The Roundtree Amagansett if the better fit comes down to a different room style or availability on the dates you need.
Journey East Hampton, The Baker House 1650, The Maidstone make more sense for travelers who expect to spend more time in East Hampton. That trade can be worth it if restaurants, shops, East Hampton plans dominate the itinerary. For a calmer Amagansett-centered trip, The Reform Club is the more natural base.
EHP Resort & Marina (East Hampton) is the cross-shop for guests who want a broader resort feel and marina setting. The Reform Club is the better call for a lower-key stay where ambiance and quiet matter more than a larger amenity footprint. Booking difficulty is listed as easy, so it is also a practical fallback when peak Hamptons weekends make the East Hampton options less convenient.
Explore Amagansett
Around this place
Discover more on Pearl
Unlock the full The Reform Club guide in Pearl, including awards, comparisons, FAQs, planning details, and nearby places.
Compare The Reform Club
| Venue | Awards | Booking Difficulty |
|---|---|---|
| The Reform Club | 2026 Vogue Best Hotels in the Hamptons | Easy |
| The Roundtree Amagansett | 2026 Vogue Best Hotels in the Hamptons2026 Mr & Mrs Smith Luxury Hotels2025 Michelin Selected HotelsSmall Luxury Hotels Member 2025 | Unknown |
| Journey East Hampton | No published awards | Unknown |
| The Baker House 1650 | No published awards | Unknown |
| The Maidstone | No published awards | Unknown |
| EHP Resort & Marina (East Hampton) | No published awards | Unknown |
How The Reform Club compares with nearby options at a similar price tier.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
What is check-in like at The Reform Club?
Expect a standard hotel check-in at 23 Windmill Lane, not a complicated arrival process. That makes it a practical pick if you want an easy Amagansett base, especially versus a more scene-forward East Hampton stay like Journey East Hampton.
When is the best time to book The Reform Club?
Book earlier if you want a quieter Amagansett stay during peak Hamptons periods, because this type of East End hotel is chosen for location as much as for recognition. If your dates are flexible, midweek is usually the easier bet than a weekend, The Roundtree Amagansett is the closest comparison for that same low-key brief.
Is The Reform Club family-friendly?
Yes, if your family wants a calm base in Amagansett rather than a busier resort setup. The hotel-style format at 23 Windmill Lane makes it easier than a more sprawling property, while The Baker House 1650 is the better comparison if you want to judge a more traditional inn-style stay.
Do loyalty programs work at The Reform Club?
Do not choose this for points hunting; the draw is the Amagansett location and recent hotel recognition from Tablet Hotels and Vogue. If loyalty benefits are a priority, compare your options carefully, since this reads more like an independent stay than a chain-style rewards play.
How is the dining at The Reform Club?
Dining is not the main reason to book, since no cuisine type is listed and the stay reads as a base-first hotel choice. If eating in-house matters more, compare it with EHP Resort & Marina (East Hampton) or The Maidstone, then decide whether the location on Windmill Lane is worth the tradeoff.
