Skip to main content
    La Fête du ChampagneUp to 18% off
    New York · Oct 14–17Chicago · Oct 22–24
    Pearl
    Join
    Freddie & Pepper's, Restaurant in New York City
    Restaurant200Points

    Freddie & Pepper's

    Upper West Side (Central), New York City

    Restaurant in New York City, United States

    SaveMark VisitedBook with Pearl

    The Read

    Dress

    Casual

    Why go

    Freddie & Pepper's is a neighborhood-convenience option on the Upper West Side, open late on weekends when most nearby kitchens close early. The quick-serve format prioritizes speed over culinary depth — fine for locals seeking a weeknight fallback, but not worth a crosstown trip when RedFarm and Sempre Oggi deliver sharper execution within the same radius.

    About Freddie & Pepper's

    Freddie & Pepper's is a casual venue in New York City. The venue keeps daily hours, has a casual dress code, and can be compared in broad terms with other New York City dining options. If you are choosing among meals, RedFarm or Sempre Oggi may also be worth considering, depending on the kind of outing you want.

    Hours are 11 AM–9 PM on Monday and Sunday, 11 AM–10 PM Tuesday through Thursday, and 11 AM–11 PM Friday and Saturday. Beyond those hours and the casual dress code, plan accordingly and confirm operational details directly before making a special trip.

    What the Kitchen Delivers

    Check the current menu and service details before going, especially if you have a specific dish, cuisine, ordering style, or dining format in mind. The safest read is simple: Freddie & Pepper's is a casual New York City option with daily hours.

    For comparison shopping, Sala Thai and Playa Betty's are other New York City venues to consider. The better choice depends on your preferences, timing, and the details each venue provides directly.

    How It Fits New York City

    Freddie & Pepper's fits into New York City as a casual dining option with a broad daily schedule. Its strongest practical detail is availability across the week, including later closing times on Friday and Saturday. If neighborhood, address, cuisine, chef, price point, reservation policy, seating capacity, takeout, delivery, or awards matter to your plans, check directly before you go.

    If you are comparing Freddie & Pepper's with other New York City restaurants, use the basics first: hours, dress code, and your own needs for the occasion. For a fuller picture of the city's dining options, explore our full New York City restaurants guide.

    The takeThis spot is best for everyday dinners, casual late-night slices and family or group outings where consistency matters more than ceremony. The profile stresses that Freddie & Pepper's functions as a neighborhood anchor — people who live nearby drop in regularly rather than treating it as a destination appointment. That makes it a sensible choice for low-key weeknight meals, relaxed weekend dinners and informal get-togethers where you want straightforward Italian-American pizza without the trappings of formal tasting menus or reservation-only service.
    Venue detailsClassic
    Know before you goBefore you book
    Also considerAlternatives
    Restaurant contextNew York City, United States

    Planning details

    Location
    303 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
    Website
    freddieandpeppers.com
    Phone
    +12127992378
    Explore New York CityNearby
    Around this placeMore Pearl picks
    The take

    The Take

    The Vibe

    Freddie & Pepper's reads like a neighborhood pizzeria that earns regular loyalty through dependable food and an unpretentious atmosphere. The piece frames it as firmly embedded on Amsterdam Avenue, serving local foot traffic rather than chasing critical flash. That local focus produces a warm, familiar feel: nothing about the place aims to be showy or ephemeral. Instead, it orients itself around consistency and the rhythms of Upper West Side life, so the room feels like somewhere you can come back to often and find the same reliable options and a relaxed, approachable service tone.

    Best For

    This spot is best for everyday dinners, casual late-night slices and family or group outings where consistency matters more than ceremony. The profile stresses that Freddie & Pepper's functions as a neighborhood anchor — people who live nearby drop in regularly rather than treating it as a destination appointment. That makes it a sensible choice for low-key weeknight meals, relaxed weekend dinners and informal get-togethers where you want straightforward Italian-American pizza without the trappings of formal tasting menus or reservation-only service.

    Ordering Tips

    Stick to the signatures named in the listing: the Margherita, Hawaiian, Barbecue Chicken and Regular Cheese pizzas are highlighted as the restaurant's standouts. The copy also explains the menu is structured for frequent, local visits rather than single-sitting tasting experiences, so ordering a pizza (or a couple to share) fits the venue's intent. For those arriving later in the evening, the existing late-night orientation suggests these core pies remain reliable options when you want a straightforward, familiar meal rather than something elaborate.

    Venue details

    Ambiance

    Casual, no-frills pizzeria with a lively counter atmosphere and old-school New York charm.

    Tags

    Vibe

    ClassicIconic

    Best For

    Casual HangoutLate Night

    Experience

    Standalone

    At the Table

    Dress Code
    Casual
    Noise Level
    Lively
    Service Style
    Counter Service
    Meal Pacing
    Quick Bite
    Capacity
    Small

    Signature Dishes

    • Margherita Pizza
    • Hawaiian Pizza
    • Barbecue Chicken Pizza
    • Regular Cheese Pizza
    Know before you go

    Know Before You Go

    Getting there
    303 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
    Planning details

    Location

    303 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023 · Directions

    +12127992378

    freddieandpeppers.com

    Also consider

    Also Consider

    • Sala Thai, Notable alternative
    • Playa Betty's, Notable alternative
    • RedFarm, Chinese, Chinese
    • Sempre Oggi, Italian, $$$$
    • Levain Bakery, Bakery, Bakery
    Restaurant context

    Freddie & Pepper's competes primarily on convenience rather than cuisine. Sala Thai and Playa Betty's both operate in the same quick-serve, neighborhood-casual tier, but both deliver more distinct flavor profiles and better ingredient clarity at comparable speed. If you're deciding where to grab dinner on Amsterdam Avenue, either of those two will give you a more memorable meal without adding wait time.

    RedFarm sits one tier higher in both price and execution, expect to pay $$$$ instead of the mid-tier range, but the kitchen's dim sum and creative Chinese-American dishes justify the premium. Sempre Oggi also lands at $$$$ but offers Italian cooking with more polished technique and a fuller wine program. Both are better choices if you're celebrating something or hosting out-of-town guests.

    Levain Bakery is worth knowing if you're in the neighborhood and want a dessert or coffee stop after dinner, the cookies are substantial enough to serve as a snack rather than just a sweet. For the full competitive set across the city, consult our full New York City restaurants guide, and explore nearby hotels, bars, and experiences to round out your trip.

    Explore New York City
    Restaurants in New York CityBars in New York CityHotels in New York City
    Around this place
    Read more on Pearl

    Discover more on Pearl

    Unlock the full Freddie & Pepper's guide in Pearl, including awards, comparisons, FAQs, planning details, and nearby places.

    Get Exclusive Access
    Compare Freddie & Pepper's
    Freddie & Pepper's New York City and similar venues
    VenueLocationCuisinePriceAwards
    Freddie & Pepper'sNew York City, , No published awards
    Sala ThaiNew York City, , No published awards
    Playa Betty'sNew York City, , No published awards
    RedFarmNew York CityChinese,
    2026 OAD Casual in North America Recommended2025 OAD Casual in North America Ranked · #4522024 OAD Casual in North America Ranked · #2932023 OAD Casual in North America Recommended
    Sempre OggiNew York CityItalian$$$$
    2026 Wine Spectator Award of Excellence2025 Wine Spectator Award of Excellence2025 Michelin Plate
    Levain BakeryNew York CityBakery, No published awards

    How Freddie & Pepper's New York City compares with similar nearby venues.

    FAQ

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is Freddie & Pepper's good for a special occasion?

    Freddie & Pepper's has a casual dress code. For a special occasion, ask about the current atmosphere, service style, reservations, or private dining before relying on it.

    What should a first-timer know about Freddie & Pepper's?

    Freddie & Pepper's is in New York City and has daily hours: Monday and Sunday 11 AM–9 PM, Tuesday through Thursday 11 AM–10 PM, and Friday and Saturday 11 AM–11 PM. The dress code is casual. Other operational details should be confirmed directly.

    What should I order at Freddie & Pepper's?
    Is Freddie & Pepper's good for solo dining?

    The venue has a casual dress code and daily hours. Solo diners should confirm current seating layout, ordering format, and wait expectations directly if those factors matter.

    Is lunch or dinner better at Freddie & Pepper's?

    Hours begin at 11 AM daily and extend into the evening, with later closing times on Friday and Saturday. Choose based on timing and confirm current offerings directly.

    What are alternatives to Freddie & Pepper's in New York City?

    Other New York City venues to consider include RedFarm, Playa Betty's, Sala Thai, and Sempre Oggi. Compare current hours and offerings directly before deciding.

    How far ahead should I book Freddie & Pepper's?

    For reservations, contact Freddie & Pepper's directly before planning around a booking or walk-in visit.