Skip to main content
    Pearl
    Join
    Blue Mermaid Island Grill, Restaurant in Kittery
    Restaurant150Points

    Blue Mermaid Island Grill

    Kittery

    Restaurant in Kittery, United States

    SaveMark VisitedBook with Pearl

    The Read

    Dress

    Casual

    Why go

    Blue Mermaid Island Grill operates Wednesday through Sunday with midday and evening hours, positioned as a walk-in neighborhood grill near Kittery's outlet district. The limited schedule and absence of reservations place it in the town's casual tier, a few steps below Robert's Maine Grill and Tulsi but potentially useful as a fallback when other options are closed. Plan around the Friday–Sunday window for the longest service hours.

    About Blue Mermaid Island Grill

    Blue Mermaid Island Grill is a casual venue in Kittery with a limited weekly schedule: closed Monday and Tuesday; open Wednesday and Thursday from 2–8 PM; Friday and Saturday from 12–8 PM; and Sunday from 10 AM–2 PM. Those hours make timing the first planning detail, especially if you are trying to visit early in the week.

    Plan around the posted schedule, particularly for early-week visits. If you are comparing nearby choices, Chauncey Creek Lobster Pier, Robert's Maine Grill, Tulsi, Moxy, Jumpin' Jay's Fish Café are other names to consider.

    What the Schedule Tells You

    Blue Mermaid Island Grill's operating window is narrow. Sunday service runs from 10 AM to 2 PM, while Wednesday and Thursday begin at 2 PM and end at 8 PM. Friday and Saturday offer the longest span, from 12 PM to 8 PM. Monday and Tuesday are closed, so those days should be ruled out when planning around Kittery's compact restaurant scene.

    How It Fits the Kittery Lineup

    Blue Mermaid Island Grill is a casual Kittery venue with a Wednesday-to-Sunday schedule. The practical comparison is availability: if its hours line up with your visit, it may be worth considering alongside other dining.

    Place it in the broader Kittery dining mix. If Kittery's other restaurants are not the right fit for your timing, Blue Mermaid Island Grill remains a casual option to evaluate by its hours before you go.

    The takeBlue Mermaid is best for straightforward coastal meals where the region’s catch is the point of the plate. Its casual, ingredient‑forward approach suits everyday outings — think easy lunches, relaxed dinners, and communal meals with friends or family who appreciate locally sourced seafood. Located on the waterfront of Kittery and tied to the Gulf of Maine’s distribution networks, it slots into the town’s dining backbone rather than the fine‑dining end of the spectrum. The restaurant works well for visitors who want a relaxed, authentic taste of northern New England’s coastal produce.
    Venue detailsWheelchair Accessible
    Also considerAlternatives
    Restaurant contextKittery, United States
    Explore KitteryNearby

    Planning details

    Location
    10 Shapleigh Rd, Kittery, ME 03904
    Website
    bluemermaid.com
    Phone
    +12077032754
    Around this placeMore Pearl picks
    The take

    The Take

    The Vibe

    Blue Mermaid Island Grill settles into Kittery’s coastal framework with a relaxed, approachable presence. The name evokes a sun‑soaked, tropical image, but the restaurant keeps its footing firmly in New England: local seafood and coastal farms shape the menu and sense of place. It reads as the casual, ingredient‑forward grill for a working harbor town — familiar rather than flashy, with a seaside immediacy rooted in the Gulf of Maine’s fast supply chain. The overall feel is scenic and charming, the kind of spot that prioritizes freshness and straightforward hospitality over pretense.

    Best For

    Blue Mermaid is best for straightforward coastal meals where the region’s catch is the point of the plate. Its casual, ingredient‑forward approach suits everyday outings — think easy lunches, relaxed dinners, and communal meals with friends or family who appreciate locally sourced seafood. Located on the waterfront of Kittery and tied to the Gulf of Maine’s distribution networks, it slots into the town’s dining backbone rather than the fine‑dining end of the spectrum. The restaurant works well for visitors who want a relaxed, authentic taste of northern New England’s coastal produce.

    Ordering Tips

    Focus on the menu’s coastal ingredients and the venue’s signature items. Standouts listed for this grill include the lobster quesadilla and the island‑braised beef short ribs, and the key lime pie is highlighted as a go‑to dessert. Because the kitchen leans on Gulf of Maine seafood and nearby farms, expect fresh, plainly prepared seafood offerings; ordering items that feature local shellfish or lobster uses the restaurant’s sourcing advantage. Save room for the key lime pie to finish a meal that balances coastal flavors with casual presentation.

    Venue details

    Ambiance

    Modern, open industrial-style space with live music, relaxed and inviting atmosphere.

    Tags

    Vibe

    LivelyRusticEnergetic

    Best For

    BrunchGroup DiningCasual Hangout

    Experience

    Live Music

    Accessibility

    Wheelchair Accessible

    At the Table

    Dress Code
    Casual
    Noise Level
    Conversational
    Service Style
    Upscale Casual
    Meal Pacing
    Standard
    Capacity
    Large

    Signature Dishes

    • key lime pie
    • lobster quesadilla
    • island braised beef short ribs
    Planning details

    Location

    10 Shapleigh Rd, Kittery, ME 03904 · Directions

    +12077032754

    bluemermaid.com

    Also consider

    Also Consider

    • Tulsi, Notable alternative
    • Moxy, Notable alternative
    • Robert's Maine Grill, Notable alternative
    • Jumpin' Jay's Fish Café, Notable alternative
    • Chauncey Creek Lobster Pier, Lobster Pound, Lobster Pound
    Restaurant context

    Against Kittery's small dining roster, Blue Mermaid Island Grill sits at the casual end. Tulsi offers the most polished experience in town, Indian fine-casual with a curated wine list and reservations recommended, making it the default choice for a planned meal. Robert's Maine Grill occupies the middle ground with tablecloth service and New England standards, easier to book than Tulsi but still a step above grill-and-go formats. Blue Mermaid's walk-in model and limited hours make it a neighborhood option rather than a destination, comparable in approach to Chauncey Creek Lobster Pier's no-reservations lobster service but without the waterfront setting that draws summer crowds.

    If you're weighing value and convenience, Robert's Maine Grill delivers more certainty, you can call ahead, check the menu online, plan a visit around predictable hours. Tulsi is the splurge pick when you want a wine-forward meal with heat and spice. Blue Mermaid becomes useful when those spots are closed (Monday and Tuesday for Blue Mermaid, but Robert's and Tulsi have their own dark days) or when you're already in the outlet district and want something quick. For visitors splitting time between Kittery hotels and Kittery bars, the Sunday brunch slot is the most reliable window, 10 AM to 2 PM gives you a landing spot before the rest of the town's dining options open for dinner.

    Out-of-town alternatives like Jumpin' Jay's Fish Café in Portsmouth offer more polished seafood menus and longer operating hours, but they require crossing the river and dealing with Portsmouth parking. If you're staying in Kittery and prefer to walk, Blue Mermaid's inland location near the outlets makes it more accessible than the harbor-side spots. For a quick grill meal on a Friday or Saturday when the kitchen is open noon to 8 PM, it's a functional option, just don't expect the ambition or consistency of the town's top two restaurants.

    Explore Kittery
    Restaurants in Kittery
    Around this place
    Read more on Pearl

    Discover more on Pearl

    Unlock the full Blue Mermaid Island Grill guide in Pearl, including awards, comparisons, FAQs, planning details, and nearby places.

    Get Exclusive Access
    Compare Blue Mermaid Island Grill
    Blue Mermaid Island Grill and similar venues
    VenueLocationCuisineAwards
    Blue Mermaid Island GrillKittery; No published awards
    TulsiKittery; No published awards
    MoxyPortsmouth; No published awards
    Robert's Maine GrillKittery; No published awards
    Jumpin' Jay's Fish CaféPortsmouth; No published awards
    Chauncey Creek Lobster PierKittery PointLobster Pound
    2024 OAD Casual in North America Ranked · #7522023 OAD Casual in North America Recommended

    How Blue Mermaid Island Grill compares with similar nearby venues.

    FAQ

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can I eat at the bar at Blue Mermaid Island Grill?

    Confirm counter or bar seating before you go. Blue Mermaid Island Grill is casual and operates in Kittery on Wednesday and Thursday from 2–8 PM, Friday and Saturday from 12–8 PM, Sunday from 10 AM–2 PM, with Monday and Tuesday closed.

    What should I wear to Blue Mermaid Island Grill?

    The dress code is casual. There is no need to plan around a formal dress expectation.

    What should I order at Blue Mermaid Island Grill?

    Check the current menu when planning your visit.

    Is Blue Mermaid Island Grill good for a special occasion?

    Blue Mermaid Island Grill has a casual dress code and limited weekly hours. It may fit a low-key visit if the schedule works for you; for a more structured occasion, confirm service style, seating, menu, reservation options before you go.

    What are alternatives to Blue Mermaid Island Grill?

    Other options to compare include Tulsi, Robert's Maine Grill, Chauncey Creek Lobster Pier, Moxy, Jumpin' Jay's Fish Café. Compare current hours and details before deciding, especially because Blue Mermaid Island Grill is closed Monday and Tuesday and opens at 2 PM on Wednesday and Thursday.