The Buccaneer Resort St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands

Should You Book The Buccaneer Resort?

Getting a room at The Buccaneer is easier than at most Caribbean resorts of comparable standing; if you're comparing booking friction, this is one of the more accessible options in the U.S. Virgin Islands. The harder question is whether the experience justifies the trip to St. Croix over the better-connected islands of St. Thomas or St. John. For a certain kind of traveler; one who wants space, a lower-key atmosphere, a resort that has been operating long enough to know what it's doing, the answer is yes.

The Buccaneer sits on St. Croix's north shore outside Christiansted, a location that rewards travelers who want to be near a walkable town without being in one. St. Croix is the least-visited of the main U.S. Virgin Islands, which means fewer crowds on the beach and at the bar. If you're value-sensitive, that matters: the island's lower tourist density translates to a more relaxed experience without a proportional drop in resort quality.

The property has been operating for decades, it's one of the oldest family-run resorts in the Caribbean, that continuity shows in the staff. Long-tenured employees who know returning guests by name are a consistent feature of guest feedback. This is what distinguishes The Buccaneer from newer boutique competitors: the human element here is institutional, not performative. For a couple or family that values being recognized and looked after over novelty design, that counts for a lot. Compare it to a freshly opened boutique property and you'll notice the difference within the first hour of check-in.

As a value-seeker's read: The Buccaneer delivers a full-service resort experience, multiple beaches, tennis, a golf course, water sports, on-site dining, at a price point that undercuts many comparable Caribbean properties. You're not paying a brand premium here. What you're paying for is a well-run, historically grounded resort with staff who have been doing this for years. That's a better deal than it sounds.

Booking is direct. St. Croix doesn't have the same flight connectivity as St. Thomas, so factor in travel time and potential connections from the mainland. Visit our full Christiansted hotels guide for context on what else is available on the island.

How It Compares

Against the wider U.S. Virgin Islands resort set, The Buccaneer holds its own on service depth but trades some luxury polish for character and accessibility. The Ritz-Carlton, St. Thomas will give you more consistent five-star service infrastructure and better flight connections, but you'll pay a meaningful premium and get a more corporate feel in return. If brand assurance and seamless logistics matter most, St. Thomas wins. If you want a resort with genuine personality and a staff that feels invested, The Buccaneer is the stronger call.

Lovango Resort and Beach Club and Caneel Bay on St. John offer more dramatic natural settings and proximity to the Virgin Islands National Park, but both skew toward travelers who prioritize seclusion and are comfortable with limited on-site amenities. The Buccaneer's full-service offering, golf, multiple beaches, structured dining, makes it the better pick for guests who want resort infrastructure alongside the Caribbean setting. Long Bay Beach Resort in Tortola is a more direct comparison for relaxed, character-driven beach resorts, but requires navigating British Virgin Islands entry logistics, which adds friction. For a U.S. passport holder who wants ease of entry, all-inclusive amenities, a resort with long-term staff, The Buccaneer in St. Croix is the most practical choice in this peer group.

Explore More in Christiansted

• Our full Christiansted restaurants guide
• Our full Christiansted bars guide
• Our full Christiansted experiences guide
• Our full Christiansted wineries guide