Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop
Washington Square West, Philadelphia
Bar in Philadelphia, United States
Book with PearlWhy go
Paulie Gee's Slice Shop on S 13th St is Philadelphia's no-reservation answer to quality counter-service pizza, drawing on the Brooklyn brand's reputation for serious dough and creative toppings. Walk in, order at the counter, eat well for a low per-head cost. Best for solo lunches, casual pairs, or a post-bar slice; not a lingering dinner.
About Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop
Who Should Go; and When
If you want a quick, no-ceremony slice on Philadelphia's South Street corridor, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop at 412 S 13th St is the right call for a solo lunch, a low-key weeknight bite, or a post-bar stop with friends. This is counter-service pizza, not a sit-down experience, so set expectations accordingly: you are here to eat a great slice, not to linger over a bottle of wine. First-timers should walk in, scan the day's options, order at the counter without overthinking it.
What to Expect Inside
The energy at Paulie Gee's Slice Shop is casual and fast-moving. The room runs loud during peak lunch and dinner windows; the kind of place where conversations happen at a raised volume and turnover is quick. Do not expect ambient calm; the draw is the pizza and the pace, not the atmosphere. For a quieter meal in the neighbourhood, you are better served elsewhere. If the buzz suits your mood, it works well. The crowd skews young and local, with a mix of neighbourhood regulars and visitors from out of town who have done their homework.
Value Per Slice: Is It Worth It?
Paulie Gee's originated in Brooklyn and built a following on creative, high-quality pies. The Philadelphia Slice Shop format is a more accessible, walk-in version of that reputation: pizza by the slice rather than whole pies, lower price points, no reservation required. For Philadelphia, where a strong slice culture exists across multiple neighbourhoods, Paulie Gee's trades on the quality of its dough and toppings rather than novelty alone. Compared to a sit-down dinner in the city, a round of slices here is one of the lower-cost ways to eat well, which makes it a practical option when you want something satisfying without committing to a full restaurant bill.
Specific prices were not available at time of writing, but slice shops in this tier in Philadelphia typically run in the $4–$7 range per slice. Confirm current pricing on arrival. No bookings are required, which removes the main friction point.
Practical Details
| Detail | Paulie Gee's Slice Shop | Comparison Benchmark |
|---|---|---|
| Booking required | No, walk-in only | Most casual slice shops: walk-in |
| Price per head (est.) | Low, slice-counter pricing | Below full-service pizza restaurants |
| Booking difficulty | Easy, no reservation needed | Easier than any table-service venue |
| Crowd/noise level | Loud at peak times | Similar to other counter-service spots |
| Suitable for groups | Yes, with caveats on seating | Better for small groups than large |
How It Fits Into a Philadelphia Night Out
Paulie Gee's Slice Shop works well as a standalone stop or as part of a longer South Philly evening. If you are building a night out, consider pairing it with a drink at 12 Steps Down or 1501 Passyunk Ave nearby. For a different kind of evening that includes live music and record culture, 48 Record Bar is worth knowing about. If you want to stay in the food lane, 637 Philly Sushi Club gives you a completely different format for a second course.
For broader planning across the city, Pearl's full Philadelphia restaurants guide, bars guide, hotels guide, wineries guide, and experiences guide cover the full picture. If you are curious how Philadelphia's leading bars stack up against cocktail destinations in other cities, Pearl also covers venues like Bar Leather Apron in Honolulu, Jewel of the South in New Orleans, and Julep in Houston for cross-city context.
The Verdict
Book nothing, show up hungry, keep your expectations clear: this is a quality slice counter with a Brooklyn-rooted pedigree operating in a city that takes its pizza seriously. For the price and the zero-friction entry, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop earns its place on any Philadelphia eat list, just do not confuse it with a full dining experience.
Planning details
- Location
- 412 S 13th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147
- Website
- pauliegee.com/soul-city
- Phone
- +1 215 933 0777
The take
The Take
The Vibe
Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop translates the wood-fired, Brooklyn-rooted pedigree of its full-service counterpart into a focused, fast-paced counter experience. The operation reads as serious and studied rather than casual by accident: sourcing and product discipline are foregrounded, and the format deliberately pares dining back to essentials. Set on South 13th Street amid cocktail bars and neighborhood dives, the shop fits naturally into a bustling corridor, offering a compact, workmanlike energy that complements the surrounding nightlife. It feels like a local stop that respects pizza craft while keeping the emphasis on quick, reliable slices rather than leisurely table service.
Best For
This slice shop works best as a convenient stop in a longer evening or a quick meal between neighborhood outings. It’s positioned for walk-ins and late-night crowds, making it a practical anchor for bar-hopping on South 13th Street or a fast bite before or after nearby cocktail spots. Visitors seeking a sit-down, multi-course dinner should look elsewhere; guests who value quality wood-fired pizza in a stripped-down, efficient format find this spot especially appealing. Its location in a dense dining corridor also makes it useful for casual group outings where speed and solid pizza are priorities.
Ordering Tips
Expect counter-style service and order by the slice for a fast experience—this is intentionally a pared-down format meant to be eaten standing up. Given the shop’s emphasis on disciplined sourcing and wood-fired technique, the simplest option is typically the clearest way to judge the kitchen’s approach. Treat the spot as part of a night out: it’s well suited for a before-or-after stop among the neighborhood’s bars and cocktail rooms. Walk-in availability and quick turnaround are central to the concept, so plan for minimal waits but a brisk, no-frills meal.
Venue details
Ambiance
Funky chic atmosphere with R&B and soul music, pool tables, Pac-Man games, and a lively high school cafeteria vibe.
Tags
Vibe
Best For
Experience
Format
At the Bar
- Bar Category
- Pub
- Late Night
- Open Until 2am
- Music
- 70s Soul and R&b Vinyl Records
Signature Pours
- Rotating Cocktail on Draft
- Hellboy
Planning details
Location
Also consider
Also Consider
- Tria; Notable alternative
- Almanac; Japanese-inspired craft cocktails; hyper-seasonal, in-house fermentation, Japanese-inspired craft cocktails; hyper-seasonal, in-house fermentation
- Next of Kin; Cocktails, bar snacks, Cocktails, bar snacks
- Sacred Vice Brewing – Berks (taproom); Brewery taproom; beer-focused, vinyl music selection, Brewery taproom; beer-focused, vinyl music selection
- The Bottle Shop; Notable alternative
Bar context
Against Philadelphia's bar-anchored venues, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop occupies a different lane entirely: it is food-first and drinks-secondary, which makes direct comparison to cocktail bars like Almanac or Next of Kin less useful than asking what you actually want out of the stop. If a drinks program with depth is the priority, Almanac's hyper-seasonal Japanese-inspired cocktails and in-house fermentation give you something Paulie Gee's cannot. Next of Kin covers cocktails and bar snacks in a format better suited to a longer evening. For beer over pizza, Sacred Vice Brewing's Berks taproom pairs a vinyl-focused atmosphere with a dedicated tap list; a stronger choice if the drink is the main event.
Where Paulie Gee's wins on value is the per-head cost and zero booking friction. Tria and The Bottle Shop both require more financial commitment per round and more deliberate planning. Paulie Gee's by contrast is one of the lowest-barrier quality food stops in the South Philly corridor; you spend less, wait less, leave having eaten well. The trade-off is that you are not getting an experience designed for lingering.
The practical recommendation: use Paulie Gee's as a food anchor at the start or end of an evening that moves elsewhere for drinks. Pair it with a stop at a bar with a stronger drinks program and you have covered both bases without overspending on either. If you want one venue that handles food and drinks together at a high level, look to Next of Kin or Almanac instead.
Explore Philadelphia
Around this place
Discover more on Pearl
Unlock the full Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop guide in Pearl, including awards, comparisons, FAQs, planning details, and nearby places.
Compare Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop
| Venue | Location | Cuisine | Awards |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop | Philadelphia | ; | No published awards |
| Tria | Philadelphia | ; | No published awards |
| Almanac | Philadelphia | Japanese-inspired craft cocktails; hyper-seasonal, in-house fermentation | No published awards |
| Next of Kin | Philadelphia | Cocktails, bar snacks | No published awards |
| Sacred Vice Brewing – Berks (taproom) | Philadelphia | Brewery taproom; beer-focused, vinyl music selection | No published awards |
| The Bottle Shop | Philadelphia | ; | No published awards |
How Paulie Gee's Slice Shop Philadelphia compares with similar nearby venues.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a reservation at Paulie Gee's Slice Shop?
No reservation needed; this is a walk-in slice counter at 412 S 13th St. Show up, order at the counter, eat. Peak lunch and dinner windows will be busier, so if you want a seat without waiting, aim for off-peak times.
What's the signature drink at Paulie Gee's Slice Shop?
Drink offerings are not documented for this location. The format here is a slice shop, so the focus is squarely on the pizza rather than a bar program. If a dedicated drinks experience matters to you, pair your visit with a stop at a nearby bar on the South Philly corridor.
What's the crowd like at Paulie Gee's Slice Shop?
Casual and mixed; the kind of counter that draws solo eaters, post-work groups, neighbourhood regulars in roughly equal measure. At 412 S 13th St, you're in a walkable stretch of South Philadelphia, so foot traffic keeps the room moving at peak hours.
Is Paulie Gee's Slice Shop good for a date?
Only if a low-key slice stop fits the mood you're going for. The format is loud, fast, counter-service; which works well as an opening move before drinks or a show, but not as a standalone date dinner. Use it as part of a longer South Philly evening rather than the centrepiece.
