The Four Horsemen

Is The Four Horsemen Worth Booking on a Late Night in Brooklyn?

Yes, with one condition: time your visit right. The Four Horsemen at 295 Grand St in Williamsburg is one of the more considered wine-bar-restaurant hybrids in New York City, and it earns its reputation most fully as the evening deepens. If you have been once for an early dinner and left before 10 PM, you have seen only half of what this room offers. Come back later, drink more deliberately, and stay longer.

What The Four Horsemen Actually Is

The Four Horsemen sits at the intersection of serious natural wine and casual-but-precise food, in a neighbourhood that has no shortage of ambitious restaurants. What separates it from the broader Williamsburg dining pack is the way the room shifts as the night progresses. Early sittings skew toward dinner-focused guests working through the food menu; later in the evening, the bar fills with regulars who are there for the wine list and the company, not necessarily a full meal. If you are returning after a first visit, the counter is where the real experience lives after 9 PM.

The wine program is the main reason to book. The Four Horsemen has built a reputation over several years for one of the more thoughtful natural and low-intervention wine selections in Brooklyn, weighted toward small European producers. For a regular, the practical move is to ask what is open by the glass rather than defaulting to the printed list — the selection shifts, and the staff here generally know the bottles well enough to give you a real recommendation rather than a recitation.

On the food side, the kitchen runs a menu of small, produce-driven plates that pair directly with the wine program. The dishes are not the primary draw, but they are competent and honest, and they hold up late when kitchens elsewhere have checked out for the night. That late-night kitchen reliability is a genuine point in the venue's favour if you are arriving after 9:30 PM.

Noise level is worth flagging. This is not a quiet room once it fills, and it fills reliably on weekends. If you are planning a conversation-heavy evening, earlier in the week is significantly more comfortable. Weekend late nights are for wine-first guests who do not mind a lively room.

Practical Details

Reservations: Relatively easy to book compared to much of Brooklyn's competition — plan a week ahead for weekends, walk-ins are more viable mid-week. Location: 295 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211 , Williamsburg, accessible via the J/M/Z at Marcy Ave. Dress: No code, but the crowd skews considered-casual. Leading for: Wine-focused guests, couples, small groups of two to four, late-evening visits after 9 PM. Budget: Expect a mid-to-upper range spend for Brooklyn; the wine list runs wide on price points, and you can calibrate accordingly.

How It Compares