58-22 Myrtle Ave

What to Expect at 58-22 Myrtle Ave

If you're weighing a night out in Ridgewood against the better-documented bars of Bushwick or Williamsburg, 58-22 Myrtle Ave sits in a different register entirely. It draws a crowd that has largely moved on from the performative drinking culture of the L-train corridor — regulars here tend to know each other, or at least act like they do. That self-selecting quality shapes the atmosphere more than any design decision: the room feels lived-in rather than curated, which is either exactly what you want or a reason to book somewhere with a clearer concept.

Right now, as the outer boroughs head into the slower shoulder of the season, neighborhood spots like this one earn their keep precisely because they don't ask much of you. No reservation system to fight, no dress code to second-guess, no prix-fixe commitment. If you've been once and found it comfortable, that's the consistent baseline — this is the kind of place where a second visit tends to feel more rewarding than the first, because you arrive knowing the room's rhythm rather than reading it in real time.

The crowd skews local and unpretentious, which keeps the energy lower-key than you'd find at Superbueno on a Friday or at Angel's Share on any night when the word has spread. That's a meaningful advantage if conversation matters to you. It's a less obvious advantage if you're looking for a tight cocktail program or a kitchen pulling real weight. On those counts, Attaboy NYC and Amor y Amargo both deliver more structured drinking experiences, and are worth considering if that's the priority.

Booking here is easy , as direct as outer-borough neighborhood bars get. The trade-off is that the data trail is thin: no published hours, no confirmed price range, no awards on record. Go in with calibrated expectations rather than high ones, and 58-22 Myrtle Ave is likely to deliver. Push it to anchor a special occasion and you'll probably be better served elsewhere in the city. For a broader view of what New York has to offer, see our full New York City bars guide and our full New York City restaurants guide.

Practical Details

For more New York City recommendations: hotels, wineries, and experiences. If you're planning a wider trip, Bar Leather Apron in Honolulu, Jewel of the South in New Orleans, and Julep in Houston are worth bookmarking for their respective cities.