Bar in New York City, United States

Martiny’s

1,520Pearl Points

Serious Cocktail Bar

About Martiny’s

For 2026 New York cocktail planning, Martiny's is worth targeting if drinks are the point of the night and the group is small enough to handle a harder booking. Do not treat it as a dinner substitute unless the current food offering fits your plan; this is a cocktail-first pick with major bar recognition.

Martiny's is a New York City bar with a verified recognition profile. Confirmed honors include World's 50 Best Bars #24 (2024), Top 500 Bars Best Bars #73 (2025), World's 50 Best North America's Best Bars #15 (2025), North America's 50 Best Bars 2026, Tales Spirited Awards Best U.S. Cocktail Bar Top 10, and Pearl Recommended Bar (2025).

The ideal way to evaluate Martiny's is by fit rather than by unverified assumptions about menus, seating, or service format. The available verified information supports it as a recognized bar with a smart casual dress code, but it does not confirm a full dining format, named dishes, pricing, hours, reservation rules, outdoor seating, or take-out and delivery. Readers looking for a meal-first plan should use Our full New York City restaurants guide instead.

Go for the bar recognition, not an unverified dining agenda

The practical angle here is simple: do not plan around dinner expectations unless the current offering has been checked directly through the venue's own channels. The verified facts do not establish a kitchen-led menu, specific dishes, lunch service, or a full restaurant format. Treat Martiny's as a recognized New York City bar, and confirm any food, seating, or timing details before making it the anchor of an evening.

For a first visit, keep the plan grounded in what is known: Martiny's is in New York City, has a smart casual dress code, and carries notable bar recognition. If the group wants to compare other New York City bar options, scan Our full New York City bars guide before committing. If the evening is part of a larger trip, pair that with Our full New York City hotels guide, Our full New York City experiences guide, and Our full New York City wineries guide for the rest of the itinerary.

Better for a recognition-led bar plan than an assumption-heavy itinerary

Martiny's is easiest to understand as a New York City bar with confirmed recognition. For comparison, other venues to research include Craft New York, Guardian at the W, Hidden Lane Bar, Old Town Bar, and Pete's Tavern. Those comparisons can help clarify whether the night should center on Martiny's or on a different kind of outing.

Quick reference: choose Martiny's when a smart casual, recognition-backed New York City bar is the goal. Do not rely on unverified claims about exact seating, booking difficulty, happy hour, outdoor space, named dishes, or a specific dining format without checking directly with the venue.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Martiny's have outdoor seating?

The verified information does not confirm outdoor seating. Martiny's is in New York City, and guests who require outdoor seating should check directly with the venue before planning around it. Pete's Tavern is another option to research for a different kind of outing.

Do I need a reservation at Martiny's?

The verified information does not confirm a reservation policy. Martiny's has confirmed recognition including World's 50 Best Bars #24 (2024) and Top 500 Bars Best Bars #73 (2025), so planning ahead is sensible, but guests should check the venue's current booking guidance directly. Guardian at the W is another option to compare when planning a bar night.

Is Martiny's good for groups?

The verified information does not confirm group capacity, seating format, or a specific party-size recommendation. If group fit matters, check directly with Martiny's before making plans. Old Town Bar is another venue to research.

Does Martiny's have happy hour deals?

The verified information does not confirm happy hour deals or discount pricing. The grounded draw is its recognition profile, including Pearl Recommended Bar (2025), World's 50 Best Bars #24 (2024), and Top 500 Bars Best Bars #73 (2025). If value is the priority, compare current details with Craft New York and other options before deciding.

Location

121 E 17th St, New York, NY 10003

New York City, United States

Compare Martiny’s

Comparing Martiny's to Alternatives

Venue	Cuisine	Booking Difficulty
Martiny's		Near Impossible
Guardian at the W	cocktails and small bites (rooftop bar)	Unknown
Pete's Tavern		Unknown
Hidden Lane Bar		Unknown
Old Town Bar		Unknown
Craft New York		Unknown

Key differences to consider before you reserve.

Also Consider

Guardian at the W, cocktails and small bites (rooftop bar), cocktails and small bites (rooftop bar)
Pete's Tavern, Notable alternative
Hidden Lane Bar, Notable alternative
Old Town Bar, Notable alternative
Craft New York, Notable alternative

How it compares with nearby New York choices

Against Guardian at the W, Martiny's is the stronger pick for a cocktail-focused night where recognition and bar craft matter more than skyline energy. Guardian at the W makes more sense for guests who want a rooftop setting with cocktails and small bites, especially when ambiance is the point. If the group is split between drinks and views, Guardian is the easier crowd-pleaser; if the group came for the bar itself, Martiny's is the sharper choice.

Pete's Tavern and Old Town Bar are better alternatives when value, casual pacing, or group comfort matter more than cocktail awards. They are the safer calls for a relaxed New York drinking plan, while Martiny's asks for more commitment and rewards a more focused visit. Hidden Lane Bar sits closer to the neighborhood-drinks lane, useful if the night needs less ceremony.

Craft New York is the better cross-shop when food is a real part of the decision. If dinner matters, start there and add drinks after. If the bar is the event, Martiny's is the higher-conviction choice, with the tradeoff that booking difficulty and flexibility are less forgiving.